Tag Archives: corruption

MOJ corruption being illegally denied legal aid, correspondence

On 22 October I sacked my lawyer citing irreconcilable differences after he insulted me and discriminated against me multiple times.  The final straw were two conversations where he asked me repeatedly what health care I wanted, firstly not allowing me to answer, then when I started to explain my ACC rehab plan from 2009 he told me it was meaningless.  He then started repeating the same thing about what care I wanted over and over again, one of the times he did it very slowly.  There is something seriously wrong with the man and I refuse to deal with him, also given my severe stress disorder I no longer trusted him.  He also called me things that were sexually derogatory in nature and extremely offensive to any woman my age.

I sent WGNCriminallegalAid all the correspondence  between me and the lawyer to prove my case as I have had serious issues with in the past.  Although I emailed the complaint they have refused to send me the legal aid decision electronically, they sent it by mail so I have had to type it out to post it here.   Firstly my response to their decision letter.  then you can see their decision letter which will shock you.

Last time they refused me legal aid for this current case that is now almost two years old, I was not quick enough – because I was so unwell and did not know what to do that I missed the 10 day deadline.  This time the letter dated 5 November arrived at my home on 10 November so I only have 5 days to get it done.   These complaints are very distressing – mostly because I know I will be ignored but also because of the gross injustice I am being subjected to just for wanting my ACC care reinstated after winning two reviews nine years ago.

11 November 2019

WGNCriminalLegalAid@justice.govt.nz

I disagree with the decision to withdraw legal aid and not provide another lawyer and want it reviewed by someone who isn’t corrupt for the following reasons.

  1. The first lawyer you gave me didn’t work in the Wairarapa region, it was only two days before court and I contacted him, he had never heard of me. He told me then he didn’t work in the Wairarapa and hadn’t for years. Legal Aid Services already know this from previous complaints that were ignored.
  2. The second lawyer was Jock Blathwayt and at the time there was a conflict of interest and Jock agreed it wasn’t appropriate for him to be my lawyer.  Legal Aid Services knew this and still prevented me from getting a lawyer for over a year, illegally.
  3. Preventing me from getting a lawyer not only seriously traumatised me and caused me humiliation and harm, it also delayed my case and perverted justice. Which has resulted in me being charged with 25 different minor spurious crimes since.
  4. The relationship with the lawyer broke down as my valid complaint and request to have my case reassigned proves. Which you are unjustly and cruelly ignoring. This is a valid reason to be given a new lawyer according to laws you quote.
  5. It would be an injustice for a purposely impoverished disabled Civil Society Actor in area of suicide, abusive mental health, sexual abuse care, homelessness, civil/human rights and inequality, to be denied a lawyer. Especially when I live in the district with highest rate of suicide and self-harm in New Zealand.

 

As Jock Blathwayt and I are no longer in this legally conflicting situation, if you want to reassign Jock that is fine with me. It is not me who the problem here, it is corrupted Legal Aid Services and the appalling disrespectful behaviour of your staff and lawyers like Alisdair Ross who specialise in denigrating victims of abuse with mental health issues.

 

Still horrified you stated in your letter that the first lawyer was forced to withdraw or dismissed by me when you know from previous complaints he didn’t work in Wairarapa.

 

Sincerely

Jayne R

Civil Society Activist

HUMAN SEWAGE

—————————————————————————————————————————————-

On behalf of the Legal Services Commissioner

5 November 2019

Ms J R

address

Carterton

(for enquiries: Kathryn Ross 0800 253 425)

Legal aid no: (which I won’t give you
Lawyer :   (which I will give you if you want me to)

Your Case:   Fail to answer bail: other acts/statues; Wilful Damage, Other charges < 6 mths x2

 

Dear Ms J R

About your legal aid

 

On behalf of the Commissioner, we write in response to your numerous emails requesting us to reassign this matter from Alisdair Ross to a new lawyer. We have considered your request and now respond as follows:

  1. We will not assign you a new lawyer, and we have decided to withdraw aid, because it is no longer in the interests of justice for you to receive it (s 29(a)(ii) of the Legal services Act 2011 – “the Act”)
  2. We refer to the Commissioner’s “Granting Decisions – Guidelines”, which set out the grounds for reassigning or terminating aid. The relevant part of the guidelines reads:
  • It is expected that reassignment and terminations of assignment will occur infrequently.
  • To request termination of an assignment the lead provider (lawyer) and/or aided person must submit a written request to the legal aid office, which sets out the reasons termination is sought,
  • The aided person can request a change of provider once: a second reassignment may be only in exceptional circumstances. Grounds for reassignment are:
  • Conflict of interest.
  • The provider has insufficient time available.
  • — not relevant
  • —- not relevant
  • A genuine breakdown in professional relationship such that the case is unable to be advanced.
  • ——- not relevant
  1. To date, you have had 2 lawyers assigned to act for you in these matters. We do not accept it would be in the interests of justice for a third lawyer to be assigned to represent you, or for aid to continue, for these reasons:

2.1       The 2 lawyers who have represented you are competent and experienced. They have been dismissed by you, or been forced to withdraw, for reasons which have no bearing on their competence or skill.

2.2       The Commissioner’s policy on applicants (such as yourself) requesting a change of lawyer is clear. You have previously been made aware of this policy.

2.3       Exceptional circumstances do not exist here which justify us granting you another lawyer. Any breakdown in professional relationship in this case has been caused by your behaviour towards previous lawyers.

2.4       This is not the first matter in which you have caused your relationship with lawyers to break down. We refer, for example, to legal aid file 18866786 which concerned a wilful damage charge you faced last year.   (Note from me: I had a great lawyer, Suzie Barnes, we lost the case and the two officers who violently assaulted me and threatened me with worse lied in court – but Suzie was still a good lawyer, just way out of her depth. Especially when ACC lawyers Meredith Connell threatened a judicial review that would taken months if she kept asking for the REAL NAME (they give false names) of my ACC case manager to be subpoenaed as a witness to prove she contacted me by phone and promised me my care would be reinstated. When Suzie asked for CEO of ACC instead, the big guns really came out. Suzie is not part of a huge legal company like Meredith Connell, she could not defend me. There were also other perversions of justice. As a result of losing this case I threw red washable poster paint on the white ribbon banner inside Masterton police station that said SPEAK OUT AGAINST VIOLENCE TOWARDS WOMEN and left a piece of art as well.

2.5       We refer to Cant v R (2013) NZCA 513, Pitiroi v Police (CRI-2012-463-38), and Pointon v Police (2013) NZHC 2352. These cases establish the fact a defendant is not legally represented does not necessarily mount to a miscarriage of justice, or a breach of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act (BORA).  (NOTE: I could not find these cases on any legal database.)

2.6       You have had ample opportunity and been given the right (more than once), to receive legal assistance without cost, as provided by s 24(f) of BORA. However the Supreme Court noted in R v Condon (2006) NZSC 62: “…. If the accused…. Is rightly refused legal aid….. there will have been no breach of the s 24 (BORA) rights.”  (NOTE: Found this case and it doesn’t apply to my case at all.)

2.7       Here, it is reiterated, you have been given reasonable opportunity of legal representation twice. It cannot be argued unfairness accrues to you, based on this ground.

2.8       We have no confidence, if we assigned you a third lawyer, your behaviour towards that lawyer would be different from your behaviour towards your previous lawyers. (NOTE: What behaviour, last few lawyers been OK, just not Alisdair Ross.)

3.10     S 3 of the Act imposes a duty on the Commissioner to deliver legal aid efficiently and effectively. Given the above circumstances, it would be neither efficient nor effective for us to assign a third lawyer to act for you, or for aid to continue.

 

2.S 31(2) of the Act requires us to give you a reasonable opportunity to make submissions about why aid should not be withdrawn. Accordingly we will give you 10 working days from the date of this letter to make these submissions which, once received, will be considered by us.  (NOTE:  So if they weren’t forced by law to listen to reasons for not withdrawing legal aid then they would just ignore me anyway.  Oh boy do these people hate poor people!)

 

We have written to your lawyer about this decision.

 

If you wish to discuss this further, talk to your lawyer or contact Kathryn Ross on 0800 2 LEGAL AID (0800 253 425) or by email WGNCriminallegalaid@justice.govt.nz

Yours sincerely   (lol shd have been faithfully – no sincerity in this letter)

Kathryn Ross

Grants Officer

Reconsideration rights

 

If you disagree with the decision made you may apply for a reconsideration using the reconsideration form on our website or calling Kathryn Ross………..

—————————————————————————————————————————————-

(I phoned and was told just to send an email).

This is the first time I have read the document properly and I found a whole heap of other BS I never saw before.  Like my lawyer last year Susie Barnes was a good lawyer, just way out of her depth and resources.  The lawyer I have had in the past have been OK, they all got me off vast majority of my charges – I only been convicted of 3 things – Wilful trespass of Law Society for going there and refusing to leave until I got a lawyer – graffiti a few years ago and wilful damage last year.  I have been charged with DOZENS OF CRIMES, MULTIPLE TIMES – most of the charges never even ended up in court because police would drop the charges after three months, just before it got to a serious court sitting.   Gee I wonder why!

I had to represent myself – I was capable of it then – against DHB wilfil trespass charges for a legal protest I did and I won – the case was so bad and their witness the security guard had never been told about BORA and the rights of people to protest on public property.  I asked for compensation for being put through that court case unnecessarily – I was insulted, degraded and ridiculed by the CEO at the time for even asking.

Anyway, must get back to Criminal Legal Aid and add to my complaint above – I HAVE A LOT MORE TO FKN SAY NOW.  WTF are these people on??   Lawyers don’t like me for my protests about wanting me and other mentally injured suicidal abuse victims – mostly women – to get the professional ACC treatment care rehabilitation and homes we are entitled to under NZ law.   Mmmmm the legal profession – terrorising a victim of sexual abuse who asking for health care they entitled to – now why would they possibly do that – ewwwwww.  Do you think Kathryn Ross might be these abusers in the system’s madam – just like that woman did for Geoffrey Epstein.  Ewwwww

Below are more emails I have sent to Wellington Criminal Legal Aid, I post them to show people what goes on, validate if its happening to them and to give people knowledge of how they might approach something similar.

————————————————————————————————————————-


From: Jayne R
Sent: Tuesday, 12 November 2019 5:37 PM
To: wgncriminallegalaid@justice.govt.nz <wgncriminallegalaid@justice.govt.nz>
Subject: I have more to add to my complaint and request for a new lawyer

I have just read your decision thoroughly – I was too traumatised and unwell by what I had read earlier to do it.   I see I have until the 19 November before the 10 days is up to provide the information necessary for you to consider.  I have found several other things you have said that have me in shock, especially about lawyers, my lawyer Suzie Barnes was great, just way out of her depth.  She still says hi to me in the street and has told me how deeply distressed she is that she cannot represent me due to her lack of resources and the horrendous injustices I am up against at the hands of very powerful cruel corrupt people.  Injustices all people with mental health issues are experiencing at the moment according to the United Nations human rights reports I have seen and been involved in as a Civil Society Actor.

Please advise me urgently the names of these PREVIOUS LAWYERS where there was a breakdown of the relationship because of MY BEHAVIOUR towards them????  Please advise me what that breakdown was, you must have written record of it because I cannot recall many details after this long.  You must have information on your file about what happened with each of these lawyers that is inaccurate and I am certainly not aware of.  Did the bad ones I sacked for good reason say I was mean to them and lie about what happened – gee I wonder why they would do that?

Is this something to do with how all established lawyers accept #metoo sexual harassment and denigration of women as normal within your profession/industry, because that is what it feels like.

I think I might have sacked two really bad lawyers in the past nine years since I was forced to protest about being illegally denied ACC care, cause they were both really bad and didn’t know how to deal with my BORA related criminal charges for my NON-VIOLENT LEGAL CHALLENGES of people in power.  I’m pretty sure I got better lawyers after those two and won both cases, one of them in the Appeal Court from what I remember of the years of fighting for health care and justice I am entitled to under NZ constitutional laws and signed ratified UN treaties.  Please send me the details since you are using them to terrorise and pervert justice now – least you can do is full disclosure of these allegations and what I am up against so I can refute them.

Please advise how I look up the case law you quoted about what you are doing to me not being a violation of NZ BORA – which of course it is – I hadn’t actually thought of that, thanks for the tip.  I didn’t realise I was supposed to be a qualified lawyer with access to case law in order to defend myself against the Legal Aid COMMISSIONER.  I thought the point of disabled poor people getting legal aid and lawyers was because they didn’t know the law and particularly couldn’t access things like case law to defend themselves against very powerful abusers of power, right and justice.  I am quite sure my situation is nothing like the case law you quoted, given the inaccurate and deceitful things you have referred to in your decision.

If you know I cannot access those case law examples of why you are not violating BORA through the internet then please provide copies of them in full.

Mmmm trying to think of those lawyers I had before Suzie Barnes?   I remember one guy, who was a proud member of the National party, withdrew when I said I didn’t trust him, because I don’t trust anybody, I don’t know any badly abused and neglected abuse victim who does – I was in shock and very distressed he was allowed do that.  You’ll have to remind me of any others, people with Complex PTSD who subjected to prolonged psychological, physical and economic trauma often forget things that aren’t important.

Sounds like you’ve all been discriminating against me, gossiping and illegally sharing information about me that isn’t even true.  That must be why I have experienced such toxic hatred and bigotry from Legal Aid services – I could never understand why and what was going on.  I would imagine cruel corrupt bigots within NZ police and mental health services would also have information you would be relying on, please provide anything like that as well.  Is it any wonder at the UN Human Rights consultation process last year, the lecture theatre at Victoria of about 50 people, all but two were there about serious human rights abuses against people with mental health issues – just like me.  Which it appears you are participating in with regards to me simply getting a lawyer.

From news reports and lawyers I have spoken to it appears to be more a case of lawyers choosing to do commercial and easy law for rich people that pays well, rather than actually uphold law and protect poor and disabled people from abuses of power.

I would also point out I have a serious life-threatening stress disorder with related communication impairments, especially when subjected to discrimination, degradation, insults and bigotry, as is the life of a many disabled people with Complex PTSD – as a result of sexual violence  and criminal neglect.   I have serious, well founded, trust issues and once someone loses that trust the professional relationship can break down – YOU WOULDN’T BE ANY DIFFERENT IF IT HAPPENED TO YOU.  No rich person would have accepted what was said to me, they would have got another lawyer immediately – so why should a poor person be punished and have their legal aid illegally withheld.

So please consider my email yesterday just the beginning of my evidence – you will have received all of it by the 19 November, when you can put it all together and consider it – lol.  I expect the rest of your file in the next few days so I can check it for accuracy.

Also I would like to comment that your letter was extremely litigious considering I am a disabled lay person citizen and you are a Commission, not a court.  Perhaps my idea of transferring all commissions, tribunals etc back under our traditional legal system has more merit than I first thought.

Please provide the information requested above in the next two days so I can be sure to provide all the evidence you need, within your 10 day time limit, to make a right and just decision.

I can certainly feel the bigotry, hatred and evil of passive inaction many affluent people who work in justice, welfare and health exhibit towards disabled people like myself.

Sincerely
Jayne R
Civil Society Activist
HUMAN SEWAGE

From: Jayne R
Sent: Tuesday, 12 November 2019 6:40 PM
To: wgncriminallegalaid@justice.govt.nz <wgncriminallegalaid@justice.govt.nz>
Subject: Sorry this wasn’t the case the numbers and names didn’t all match up

I can’t find Cant v R or Pointon v police or Pitiroi v police so far, please provide a link or copies of these cases.

I did find R v Condon – which has no relevance to my case whatsoever.   My wanting to sack Alisdair Ross is to do with ongoing behaviour I didn’t like but put up with, but definitely could no longer cope with after his extremely bizarre bigoted insulting behaviour of recent phone conversations about me getting my ACC care reinstated and what that involved.  Also about him making sexually inappropriate derogatory comments calling me a Cougar – ewwwww – which I had not done anything about, except tell him how bad it made me feel – which he did not acknowledge or apologise for.  I felt it necessary to mention it after the phone calls as it was relevant and I should have made a formal complaint about it but was too scared I would end up with no lawyer and after the appalling treatment I had received from Legal Aid Services and Law Society in the past knew they would just abuse me for it.  #metoo and kia kaha to all those innocent young women in the misogynist world of law.

EVERYBODY had been telling me for ages my criminal case had nothing to do with ACC illegally withholding health care and I even have a criminally corrupt psychiatric report to say I was delusional for even thinking my criminal case and civil rights abuses by ACC and others were related.  So the discussion Alisdair and I were having wasn’t even related to my criminal case, it was related to what health care I needed, entitled to by law and wanted from ACC.  Apparently ACC had a list of OTs to choose from and as soon as I made the decision my care would be reinstated after waiting nine years and winning two reviews.   As they have said this at least three times before over past nine years and failed to do it I would only believe something like that unless it happened.  ACC telling a lawyer (or ACC reviewer) they will do something doesn’t mean it will happen, ACC have told lots of people my care would be reinstated but it never did.   Also I have been in regular contact with ACC begging for my care to be reinstated, they have never sent me a list of OTs to choose from.  The one they guaranteed would reinstate my care last year refused to do it WITHOUT REASON – I made complaints, they were ignored.

My situation makes the Condon case irrelevant and that you quoted it, you corrupt!  If you want to get really legal about it.  I don’t blame the lawyer from withdrawing, I would have as well, this was a business deal gone wrong, nothing to do with politics or civil, disabled, human, economic social and cultural rights and violations of criminal law by police, ACC, Forensic Mental Health, DHB, etc WHICH MY CASE IS ABOUT.   Thank you so much for the information though, its really interesting.  I was at law school before I was raped and my life destroyed by ACC and those supposed to care for, rehabilitate and protect mentally injured victims of crime.  It took me until 35 yrs old to work out what I wanted to be and it was all taken from me.  I now live destitute and still fighting for ACC entitlements so I can heal, return to work and be able to live with dignity and in safety, now I am 54 I am not allowed a student loan.  I also live with a $7,000 student debt from trying to get the qualifications to follow my talent and my passion.

Sincerely
Jayne R
CSA
HUMAN SEWAGE

From: Jayne R
Sent: Tuesday, 12 November 2019 7:08 PM
To: wgncriminallegalaid@justice.govt.nz <wgncriminallegalaid@justice.govt.nz>
Subject: I have searched the following database I found with no results, do these cases you refer to even exist?

Below is the database I searched with all the information you gave me about the case law you were relying on – they all came up NO SEARCH RESULTS.

I would have thought with all those numbers and details at least something would have come up.  Do these cases even exist, are you that corrupt you make these things up to mislead and further oppress disabled oppressed #metoo victims of crime?  I know there is a huge amount of evidence being presented by victims against Crown Law perverting justice in the current inquiry into abuse and torture in government institutions.  Quoting Crown Law case in regards to a sexual abuse victim, fighting for treatment care rehabilitation and home they are entitled to in order to recover and return to as normal a life as possible under ACC and other laws, seems to me an even more evil crime against victims.   What do you think?

I am due in court again on 18 November I will make sure to provide this information to the judge

Yours sincerely
Jayne R
CSA
HUMAN SEWAGE
P.S.  Using Yours sincerely  on Kathryn Ross’ decision is deeply disturbing, faithfully is the correct salutation.  That you sincerely just vomited such a vicious, hate filled, unprofessional, immoral, uncivilised, vindictive, unjust, punitive, oppressive, deceitful, ignorant response all over me would explain the gross constitutional rights abuses I am subjected to.  It seems understandable that police will violently assault me & threaten me with worse and ACC & public mental health services will prevent me from accessing services I am entitled to, why wouldn’t they – nobody is going to do anything about it.

Check out discussion on my Youtube video, it explains lots

Link at below

You havn’t been listening to me – you are obsessed with this idea that we are individuals and don’t need other people – which is grossly untrue.  I’ve met three GOOD health professionals in 17 years, all of them were completely committed to supporting the person to heal in the way they needed to.  That is what Occupational Therapy is all about.  And I will again say THERE IS NO HEALING WHILE THE PERSON IS LIVING IN FEAR WITHOUT THE BASIC NECESSITIES OF LIFE LIKE SHELTER AND FOOD SECURITY.  Which currently is 20% of the NZ population 1 million people – mostly women and youth.   Gee and NZ has highest OECD stats in youth suicide and women self-harming – go figure.

Also, what might apply to a man DOES NOT APPLY TO A WOMAN, especially in the domain of trauma.  Men have to be self-reliant in more ways, although they still need ‘brothers’ – women are different we are NATURALLY reliant on men for safety and others for talking our problems through.  I don’t have a man for protection and my female friends are themselves so traumatised they can’t handle me talking about my fear of police and compulsory incarceration under mental health act FOR TELLING THE FKN TRUTH AND ASKING FOR HEALTH CARE I AM ENTITLED TO.

Mental health workers are bunch of self-righteous power tripping either psychopaths or co-dependents – mostly idiot Christians and deeply depressed people with revolting personalities that nobody would be friends with so they get into that line of work for the ego boost.  That is why I have so many problems with mental health services who genuinely HATE me and discredit me in the community cause I criticise them for making my region No 1 in NZ for suicide.  I’m intelligent, I understand my disorder, I know the law and rehab, I know how they are supposed to behave and when they do it wrong, I know the science, I know politics.  I can see straight through an abuser or a co-dependent CLINGON.

I agree with your sentiment but you’re just not understanding what we are both suggesting is essentially the same thing, I just know more of the jargon.  I studied Health 101 and rehab at Massey University for a year by correspondence.   When told to read a chapter I read the book plus I got out every book I could on trauma and studied that far beyond 1st year level.  I learnt their jargon, I learnt their models – that’s where I discovered Mason Durie and Whare Tapa Wha.   I become highly suicidal at the end and could not continue my area of study – BECAUSE I KNEW THEY WERE NOT APPLYING ANY OF THESE THINGS IN THE AREA OF HEALTH FOR MENTALLY INJURED ABUSE/TRAUMA/NEGLECT VICTIMS – it made me more unwell knowing this.  Although the jargon I learnt taught me how to interact with them using their language and proves without doubt in the area of Complex PTSD they are persecuting people purposely – we are the new Jew.

Was researching new Suicide Prevention maggot in Wairarapa, he has made completely inaccurate statements for years that mentally ill people are not violent or dangerous – WTF.   One of the symptoms of Complex PTSD is violence according to all scientific literature I have ever read!!!  Govt and police and MH know it as well.  They study same books/information I do.  This ignorant bigot started his new job by putting even more propaganda in the local free newspaper and other media – the same organisations that dont’ work for 80% of us because they are filled with issue ridden psychopaths and co-dependents, as I said before.  Combine that with the regular meetings they all have with mayors, local ‘social’ business leaders, MH services and police of course – so they all think the same BS – and I know my name comes up regularly.

Show less

New Zealand Police advised of lawyer & mental health services perverting justice


From: Jayne R
Sent: Friday, 18 October 2019 11:41 AM
To: HANSEN, Jennifer <Jennifer.Hansen@police.govt.nz>
Subject: Another person perverting course of justice

Here is another complaint about my current lawyer perverting justice as well Jennifer.  Maybe if you and corrupt senior police who have illegally, cruelly and corruptly refused to protect me and uphold my valid complaints against ACC and others govt/health sector criminals, this wouldn’t be still happening to me and 100,000s other disabled mentally injured vulnerable abuse victims living in poverty.
POLICE ARE PEACEKEEPERS NOT SOLDIERS!!!!!!!!!!!!!   They aren’t there to ‘keep nz safe’  they are there to insure law is upheld so people like me aren’t harmed!  They are there to keep the peace between rich and poor more than any other organisation – WHY AREN’T YOU JENNIFER!!!!!!!!!   Did you watch the Prof Zimbardo video about why you are acting the way you do and you can stop at any time you want you know – your passive inaction is evil and you know it.  You’re a woman, why are you harming #metoo?
I’ve put a copy of this email on my website – have you all seen it????  Just thought I’d send a special copy to you, knowing how much you think of your staff and like to know what is going on.   I’ll be putting a copy of this email on there too and talking about it on my youtube channel!  First you have to expose corruption and cruelty before you can address it!
Sincerely
Jayne R
CSA
HUMA SEWAGE

From: Jayne R
Sent: Friday, 18 October 2019 10:22 AM
To: Alisdair Ross <shwedagon@xtra.co.nz>
Subject: As you don’t comprehend anything I say I’ll put it in writing – Please put the details of what you told me yesterday in writing also

Alisdair,
Firstly I want everything you told me yesterday in writing, about your ILLEGAL conversations with Forensic Mental Health and ACC and conversations with Judge Morris where I was not present.   You did not get my written authority to discuss anything with ACC, you didn’t turn up remember.   Your contact with Forensic Mental Health is…………………

Extensive corruption in mental health & legal sectors targeting people with Complex PTSD

Got a phone call from my lawyer yesterday, he continues to refuse to put anything in writing.  This was my reply, details how bad things are in THE VIOLENCE AND PERSECUTION OF THE POOR INDUSTRY.


From: Jayne R
Sent: Friday, 18 October 2019 10:22 AM
To: Alisdair Ross <shwedagon@xtra.co.nz>
Subject: As you don’t comprehend anything I say I’ll put it in writing – Please put the details of what you told me yesterday in writing also

Alisdair,

Firstly I want everything you told me yesterday in writing, about your ILLEGAL conversations with Forensic Mental Health and ACC and conversations with Judge Morris where I was not present.   You did not get my written authority to discuss anything with ACC, you didn’t turn up remember.   Your contact with Forensic Mental Health is deeply disturbing and illegal behaviour under the Privacy Act as you definitely had no authority to contact them.  Your repeating over and over again what good people they were and how they wanted to help when I have been screaming for services for over a decade and am in court currently on 23 police charges for protesting about THAT FACT (or the past nine years of being continually dragged through court for my legal protests that I was not getting health care and justice I entitled to.

You repeatedly asking me what I wanted for mental health care (reinstatement of my ACC care from 2009) and telling me those people at mental health are trying to help me is also extremely insulting.  You must have asked me what I wanted 10 times,  when I told you some of the things you asked the question again, like I hadn’t even spoken.  At one point you slowed right down and said the same words really slowly like I was some sort of imbecile – it was offensive and extremely disrespectful.  Which is why you triggered me, you are really good at it to the point I think you enjoy it and do it purposely.  My previous lawyer Susie Barnes would never have triggered me like that, or kept doing it when I said to stop.   I believe you are grossly corrupt Alisdair and have a hidden agenda working for some elite group of psychiatric and legal terrorists targeting poor abuse/trauma victims with Complex PTSD like myself.  As you already know Legal Aid will refuse me a lawyer if I sack you and I am still to unwell to represent myself so I have no choice but continue working with corrupt fascist bigot and elitist terrorist.

For past nine years those corrupt deceitful criminals at mental health have asked me the same question about what I wanted and then never done what they promised MANY MANY TIMES.  This is psychological torture that has destroyed my life and my relationships – that I doubt will ever be repaired because of what they have done!  DESTROYED MY FAMILY and doing their best to DESTROY ME!!!!!

Obviously these incompetent ignorant bigots in Forensic Mental Health want me to tell them how to fix it for me and 100,000s people with Complex PTSD.  As a result of interpersonal violence, combined with the inhuman living situations our government now expect disabled mentally injured people (mostly women) to survive and HEAL in – let alone thrive.  Although I am sure you all know this isn’t going to happen while govt bring 3,000 immigrants a week into New Zealand to drive disabled and poor locals from their homes, health care and justice.   I see in a news item today unemployment is past 10% for poorest and youngest New Zealanders, so rich educated immigrants are taking jobs from locals and homes.  It also talks about how much poorer people rotting on invalids benefit are than they have ever been because of huge increases in rent which I am subjected to in a private rental.  You are sick sick people Alisdair, those are your peers doing this aren’t they Alisdair.

MY CARE IS SUPPOSED TO CONSIST OF:

Firstly it is to be professional and based on an internationally recognised rehabilitation model and ACC legislation.  I REFUSE TO HAVE A SOCIAL WORKER IN ANY TYPE OF THERAPEUTIC ROLE, I’ve been watching the sort of harm they do with people I know.  Everything Kumar says in his book Multidisciplinary Approach to Rehabilitation, which was the academic information I was taught while studying rehabilitation at Massey several years ago, that ACC and others do not apply.

I will not participate in any unprofessional experimental therapeutic work that I know does not work for people with CPTSD.  Experimenting on people is illegal under BORA and Human Rights treaties.

My care – as with any person who has a serious life-threatening debilitating disorder – will be overseen by a psychiatrist that follows/applies the work of Mason Durie and his Whare Tapa Wha model.  I would like Mason or Dr Alan Doris (who escaped to Australia) to recommend that person so I don’t get another arrogant, corrupt, incompetent, imperialist, ignorant, elitist bigot.

BEcause of the extreme trauma ACC caused removing all my care illegally in 2009, six months into a 2 1/2 yr rehab plan, I demand a contract be signed that my care will not be withdrawn without the agreement of at least two of my closest health providers, without this it will take many months (if at all) for me to trust what is happening and participate fully in therapy out of terror of another withdrawal that will this time kill me through suicide.

I had an OT two hours a week who helped me work out where the barriers were and what I could do to overcome the now multiple phobias I have to cope with.  My previous OT was the conduit between me and the services I needed, instructing the workers at the gym I was attending about my behaviour, liasing with any education or other organisation I became part of (if that is appropriate).  I have seen multiple programmes in prisons described in news reports that are currently not available for victims like myself.  Personally I would rather not commit a serious enough crime to end up in prison so I can access these therapy’s, eg theatre.  I also think it deeply flawed to be providing therapy to people once they have harmed people or committed crimes and not before.  Although I understand why because I attended the Victoria University, Gabrielle Maxwell organised on the Costs of Crime and how to funnel funding and services into these ‘criminals’.

I had previously a mental health worker for 3 hours a week, I need at least 15 hours a week and for that to be increased DEPENDING ON WHAT HAPPENS WITH THE OCCUPATIONAL THERAPIST AND PSYCHIATRIST.   You don’t seem to understand a therapeutic relationship, the idea is we work TOGETHER to reinstate me as much as possible to my previous level of functioning before the rape.  Where I was a business franchise owner and law student with two children.  I don’t have my children at home any longer which is no less stress for me as I am now living extremely isolated with more serious psycho-social issues following years of criminal neglect by ACC and mental health and discrimination in the community.

I must work, I must be able to rejoin the workforce OR I AM GOING TO DIE!   Nobody can safely or with inherent dignity live on welfare in this neo-liberal nightmare country as it is now constructed under neo-liberal terrorist economics.  As the Newshub report I read this morning outlines – I note this is the first time in 35 years any mainstream New Zealand news service has showed evidence of poverty worsening for those receiving welfare benefits.   It was disturbing to see elderly on benefits (some still working at good jobs and receiving old age pension) have had increases in their welfare benefits while disabled and poor were impoverished further.

Currently my talents lie in the arts, that is part of the stress disorder that you become highly creative when you are extreme stressed with life and death situations constantly – which I am when the suicidality wells up.  I need help with applying for funding and educating myself as to how best to profit from my work SO I CAN PAY FOR MY OWN HOUSE AND MY OWN FOOD AND PEOPLE DON’T DESPISE AND DEMEAN ME FOR HAVING TO BEG.   I am now phobic about asking for things from people after past 17 years of dealing with ACC, justice system and mental health, this prevents me from being able to market, publish, perform and profit from my talent/my work.

Until I am healed I cannot see me being able to work at a ‘normal’ job because I am still most phobic about going for a job interview and as I know from years of experience, people will judge and reject me as being insane on just one meeting if I present in a  triggered traumatised state (as my disability is situational).  This is also hampered because of the lies mental health, police and others have spread in the community and of course my deteriorating mental health due to ACC and others.  I am discriminated against often and I challenge people with my activism which they don’t like – because it is true.  So getting a job will be almost impossible in Wairarapa and the way government agencies and members of parliament are currently terrorising me through the courts my knowledge and skills in mental health will not be taken advantage of by government – so I would never get a job for the government in any capacity – ALTHOUGH THEY DESPERATELY NEED MY HELP TO STEM THE SUICIDE EPIDEMIC they purposely created.

There will be no HOT POTATO CARE (please refer to medical evidence by world expert Karlen Lyons-Ruth), where I am given services and they are removed as soon as I show any improvement – only to let me crash and retraumatise me even more because I am not ready and KNOW IT!    I CAN ASSURE YOU THE SOONER health providers ARE OUT OF MY LIFE THE BETTER I WILL BE – RELYING ON ABUSIVE UNRELIABLE UNPROFESSIONAL HEALTH SERVICES IS WORSE THAN HAVING NO SERVICES AT ALL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!  Which is why we have so much suicide in New Zealand of course!

The OT or the mental health worker, (whoever is the more suitable or trusted – because I DO NOT TRUST ANY PERSON ON THIS PLANET, PARTICULARLY ANY HEALTH ‘PROFESSIONAL’ to do what they say) must be available to take me to the doctor. This is my most essential issue at the moment after being prevented from seeing a doctor due to an illegal and cruel CONTRACT Carterton Medical Centre (written by Simon Watt from Compass Health & Bell Gully) made me sign over three years ago.   The same threats of having all my health care removed by CMC have recently been extended to WINZ and also the local library when I burst into tears because of an email about being arrested AGAIN.  Apparently I am supposed to leave the building, compose myself and return.  Except it is the very act of going into these government buildings/situation and being demeaned, degraded and discriminated against that sets off the more extreme expressions/impairments/behaviours of my CPTSD – like self-harming.   Years of this sort of treatment has caused serious psychological harm, which is evident from my behaviour.

JUDSON AND WALSH’S ASSESSMENT THAT I AM PERMANENTLY IMPAIRED IS NOT ACCURATE AT ALL – that these ‘senior’ mental health professionals believe that would explain the appalling state of mental health services in New Zealand.  The idea that I am going to be like this forever is utterly ridiculous if I get the professional treatment care rehabilitation and housing I am entitled to under New Zealand law!   If I don’t get that care of course things will not improve and I will die – which I am sure is what our government, the legal profession and the health profession want to keep people employed in VIOLENCE/MENTAL HEALTH INDUSTRY.

Wanting me to provide every last detail of care IS NOT HOW REHABILITATION WORKS, that you don’t know that Alisdair could be explained – how leading psychiatrists and ACC don’t know that is incompetent, negligent and discrimination.  I would be working with an expert psychiatrist in the field of traumatic stress disorders, I guarantee you this person will know what is happening – just like OT Glenda van de ven Long did when I was working with  her.  Just like Dr Alan Doris did when I talked to him during several assessments – but was never allowed him as my psychiatrist – CORRUPTLY AND ILLEGALLY.

Part of my rehabilitation must include a full gym membership as I need the support of the staff, plus I have other physical health issues that now need to be addressed and will limit what I can do.  My previous OT facilitated my going to gym.  I need a full medical (to see a doctor more than once) as I have concerns about skin cancer, my ankle and hip as well.  I become easily overwhelmed and would not cope initially with a long consultation as I am terrified of doctors after the appalling bigoted incompetent unprofessional disrespectful treatment I have received.

I need a professional needs assessment ONCE I HAVE BECOME FAMILIAR WITH THE PEOPLE I AM WORKING WITH – and there cannot be more than three people or organisations who are expected to know my impairments and assist me in firstly managing them and then overcoming them WHICH IS ALL I HAVE EVER WANTED!!!

ACC need to provide someone to deal with the years of unopened mail caused by them REFUSING TO REINSTATE MY CARE AS REQUIRED BY TWO ACC REVIEWS IN 2010/11.   ACC need to provide a professional to insure I get the $10,000+ in independence allowance they have been illegally withholding for years and I WILL NOT BE REQUIRED TO ATTEND YET ANOTHER ASSESSMENT TO GET THAT MONEY – that was required to be reinstated in 2010 according to the Fairway Review.

I also had monthly massages in 2009 which need to be weekly, when the gym is reinstated as it balances out the activity and release of rage with calm and quiet.   Yin and yang.  This also works psycho-socially as I am touched in a good healing way, not an abusive way.  That I have to explain why I need and am entitled to these things under law, to my lawyer and top government psychiatrists is not only strange its completely inappropriate.  A rehabilitation plan is developed between health professionals and the disabled person – not during a court case for protesting about being denied the professional treatment care rehab and home I am entitled to under ACC law & many other laws and UN treaties.

The six week residental rehabilitation programme I was supposed to go on years ago, as stated by Dr Alan Doris, will need to be organised.  Given our cruel corrupt government removed all the places that were suitable this will need to be part of $millions government have pledged to increase in services/resources for people with more acute mental health issues, especially as a result of abuse.   People with CPTSD are not accommodated by public mental health services, I read a news report by the new suicide prevention officer at Wairarapa DHB who said people with mental illness were not violent.   Violence is a symptom of Complex PTSD according to Bessell van der Kolk, whose work I greatly admire.  If only we would listen to the artists to guide services/resources as he suggests in his great book Traumatic Stress Disorders.  Copies of which I showed both forensic psychiatrists assessing me.

Personally I do not allow myself to act on the violence I feel and use my activism, self-harm and other techniques so I don’t become violent.  These so far work very well and I have never been violent towards any person, however I am treated like I am violent.  I recall the first time I started protesting about not getting mental health services I was entitled to from ACC my police file says on it DANGER TO POLICE SAFETY.   I was never and have never been a danger to police safety, I believed police were there to uphold justice and the law, my brother in law was a senior police officer, I didn’t realise there are corrupt police officers who are dedicated to protecting corrupt criminal people in power and persecute honest disabled people fighting for their rights to health care and justice.

Hopefully this answers your question about WHAT HEALTH CARE I WANT, making it clear this is not the full extent of what I am entitled to and need AS I WOULD REQUIRE THE APPROPRIATE HEALTH PROFESSIONALS AND MODELS TO BE PUT IN PLACE TO INSURE AND WORK THAT OUT!!!!!!!!!!!

You said I have to meet with you, which I have no choice about, however you must organise it through Masterton District Court, it will be recorded BY ME and security guard Jason will need to be there to support me and protect you in case I can’t keep control of the overwhelming rage I feel at what you and your friends at Forensic mental health are doing to not just me – to 100,000s of desperate innocent terrorised poor abused people – mostly women.   YOU DRIVE CHILDREN TO SUICIDE AND PEOPLE TO VIOLENCE AND SELF-HARM – you people are murderers and oppressors of the worst form.  How you sleep at night knowing what you do is beyond my comprehension as a civilised decent person.

In the future please communicate with me through email so I have proof of what you are saying and as requested at the beginning of this email please advise the details of who you have been talking to and what you have been doing that you advised me of yesterday in your telephone call.

Sincerely

Jayne R
Civil Society Activist
HUMAN SEWAGE

New Zealand Public Law Academics lead the evil of passive inaction- Dr Edward Willis

I got hold of Edward Willis expert in public/constitutional law and lecturer at Auckland University, started off saying he was willing to help.  Took a look at my website and this is what he text me – even after asking him to phone me he so riddled with guilt he couldn’t do it.  Look how strange his responses are, especially at the end when he says he isn’t safe.  Safe from what – the truth.

Text messages as follows

FROM WILLIS

Wed 9 Oct 2019 1:55pm

Hi Jane, It’s Edward Willis – you have left a couple of messages on my phone.  I have been overseas since Friday and am just back at my desk today.  I am getting through a heavy workload at the moment but perhaps if you would please email me with some specifics of the issues you are facing I can assess whether they are the sort of thing I can help with Edward.willis@auckland.ac.nz I am in meetings for the rest of the afternoon but will look at anything you send me as soon as possible.

MY RESPONSE

Wed 9 Oct 2019 3:59pm

Hi, I have communication issues I better talking with someone.  Firstly check out my website www.jrmurphypoet.com & youtube JR Murphy Poet.  You will have to excuse my angry response to your news item I have serious legal issues related to public law violations.  Prove me wrong and get me justice I should have and I’ll take down the video and do a different one.  But do not treat me like I don’t know the law & my rights as a poor person in a commonwealth democracy.  Particularly the 2 recent psych reports.  Thank you

Thu 10 Oct 2019 10:01 am

Best we talk before you form any opinions of me and the value of my current criminal case in upholding vital constitutional laws of nz and the commonwealth.  That’s without actually getting the lawyer I am entitled to for past 15 yrs for the fundamental injustices me and others being subjected to under neo-liberalism.

FROM WILLIS

Thu 10 Oct 2019 10:33am

Hi Jane, I did take a look at your website yesterday evening. My impression was that you have a number of concerns with New Zealand’s law/government but nothing struck me as being an issue where I would genuinely be able to offer you meaningful assistance.  In particular I am not currently a practicing lawyer and so cannot lawfully provide you with any legal advice.  I appreciate that this is probably not the response you were hoping for but I would not want you to waste your time and energy with me.  If in the future there are particular issues that you consider I may be able to genuinely help with you are still welcome to email me setting those matters out.  If it is something I believe I can assist you with then I will.  In the meantime, take care. Ed

MY RESPONSE

Thu 10 Oct 2019 10:55am

Response as expected.  You can help me, you have entire university of young people to advise me.  Best most frank discussion I had about power of constitutional laws was with 3rd yr student outside Supreme Court beside Victoria Law school.  My case needs to be in a higher court they refuse, which also deprives me of expert lawyers like Judith Ablet Kerr or Mae Chen.  I have a previous case also needs to be appealed serious perversions of justice by ACC and their lawyers Meredith Connell.

11:01 am

Also I have grounds for a judicial review but can’t work out how to do it.  Show me how or find someone who will.  Community law refused to help me.  I have nobody to discuss my defences with, my laywer always 2 hours late for meetings and supports mental health.  Did you see my solutions and rehab model for mental health?

FROM WILLIS

11:13AM

Unfortunately I am not in a position to use my students for this kind of thing.  Can I suggest you make contact with the student run Equal Justice Project.  They may be able to assist you.

MY REPLY

Thu 10 Oct 2019 11:29am

What a cop out.  Injustice is what you profit from.  You’ll get your rewards in heaven.  Every women and child who dies from suicide or domestic violence is your evil with your passive inaction.  Just as Prof Philip Zimbardo outlines in his work on abuses of power.  You should stop making public comment on constitutional law, its deceitful.

FROM WILLIS

11:32am

Hi Jane, While I have initially tried to be helpful I have now decided that it is not safe or appropriate for me to continue a dialogue with you.  I wish you well but please do not contact me again.

MY RESPONSE

11:36am

Won’t be – guilt response classic behaviour as well.

………………………………………………………………………………….

Mmmmm anybody have any idea what NOT SAFE and NOT APPROPRIATE means???  Not safe for him emotionally perhaps and not appropriate in what way, he’s one of the top law academics in New Zealand – YOUR AND MY TAXES PAY HIS WAGES!!!!  (I pay GST which is a higher percentage of my income than people who earn more.) He’s a public servant bleeding us peasants dry and working for wealthy elites to pervert constitutional law in our regard – not uphold it.  Did you like my Christian references, seemed appropriate considering the how much the bible is tied to truth and law.

Its this sort of low life bludging public servant you are paying upwards of $300,000 a year to make sure poor people are both created by the government, destroyed and exploited if they can by the government and society.  They have also set it up for themselves so they earn lots more money on the side with directorships, shares etc..  While I remain rotting on invalids benefit thanks to ACC you pay me $25,000 and I work to try and get people the health care, welfare and justice they are entitled to under law so they can return to work and lead decent lives being valued members of society.  (Wish is actually supposed to be his job.)

And NO you don’t pay my wages if you don’t agree with welfare, my 2 daughters pay my wages with the taxes they pay every week.  If you are a person who hates disabled people on welfare due to lack of health care YOU PAY FOR the $millions in interest every year on the $50billion government debt.  Which TAXPAYERS ARE WASTING THEIR MONEY ON because politicians gave the super rich tax cuts of over 40%.

Or you pay for all the ex PMs and MPs of New Zealand and their spouses who continue to get money & travel perks after quitting their jobs – where they caused huge social and environmental problems others have to try and sort out. Or what about the $2,000 a day Paula Rebstock was paid of your taxes for TRANSFORMING CYFS into Oranga Tamariki – that is on top of all her board fees as Chair of ACC and other organisations.   Then the cost of the National party making her a DAME for her services to business.  Then of course there are all the double dipper old people in good jobs who start getting TAXPAYER handouts of over $250 a week in benefit payments until they can be driven out of their cushy jobs.

When our media and National party go on about beneficiaries as they have started to in order to incite hatred in their voting demographic – just remember all the very highly  TAXPAYER paid people who work for the government and create this nightmare for some and utopia for others.

 

 

 

 

This is what $120,000 wage increase to CEO of TVNZ gets you – HATE AGAINST POOR

Here it is, always starts about 13-14 months before a general election – the National party right wing haters start trashing poor people on benefits.  And here is what THE TAXPAYERS  $1.5 million salary to the CEO of TVNZ gets you – with the promoted and justified latest $120,000 increase.  YOUR TAXES FOLKS, YOUR TAXES.

This news item is nothing more than government propaganda and we all know the rubbish we are forced to watch on TVNZ nowadays, which includes huge amounts of advertising.  Advertising limits on TV were removed when neo-liberal terrorists took over New Zealand in 1984.  As manufacturing jobs were driven overseas to ‘developing’ countries like China they needed people to become consumers, advertising brainwashing has done that – and destroyed our society and planet at the same time.

Remember every cent a beneficiary spends in the community, they support small and medium sized business profits.  Most of these people are part of the REQUIRED UNEMPLOYED for a low wage economy like we have.  Many working part-time, many with injuries & disabilities who can only work part-time and are penalised for it.  At the moment if you are on invalids benefit and get a small job of less than 15 hours a week you will get less money working than if you didn’t.  Years of cruel elitist governments did that purposely.

This news item should never have been written or published and if it was, the comparison should have been how much money is lost in contract overpayments to businesses who DON’T STAY WITHIN THEIR OFFICIAL QUOTES.  Cost overruns on public projects by private enterprise that cost TAXPAYERS $billions.

 

https://www.tvnz.co.nz/one-news/new-zealand/exclusive-taxpayers-1-billion-pocket-because-overpayments-beneficiaries?fbclid=IwAR0NzDh5_pKpVSp-na0vCFIctaD3Iy7ilxgh252NW3cd2ix1by12lbZp7ew

 

Elisabeth Brunt Head of Ministerial Services at MSD corrupt ignorant bigot or STUPID?

Refer to the letter I received from Eades on my previous post

From: Jayne R
Sent: Wednesday, 28 August 2019 3:23 PM
To: Michele Eades <michele.eades001@msd.govt.nz>
Subject: I just got your letter and can’t stop crying

Ms Eades,
I am horrified by your letter, especially after the recent amount of publicity around the highest suicide rate in New Zealand history, which made me and many other people very unwell.
Please advise what inappropriate abusive names I used.   How was I verbally abusive when I was at WINZ???  (did not answer this question)   I desperately need a mental health support worker I am entitled to under law to assist me dealing with your organisation.
It was very distressing the way you pretended you didn’t know about ACC refusing me services and mental health refusing me services.  The reason I now interact with you rather than Tina Hemi who did try and get me services after putting AWAITING TREATMENT on my forms for the past nine years.
I am not managing in my life and I am refused all support, which you already know, which is why the meetings arranged last year were cancelled.    When I read your insulting, degrading, offensive, bigoted letter I phoned all the people on your list about support.
The GP practice manager I have emailed several times since I was told I was at the bottom of a 600 people waiting list to register with a Carterton doctor.   I was told I was not allowed to register with any other doctor in New Zealand, only those at Carterton Medical Centre.   As you know I would have to pay $75 to see a doctor if unregistered.   My entire budget for the week is $79 and you know I can’t borrow any money from WINZ because I can’t pay it back – I can’t live with dignity now.
I am too terrified to phone mental health service after being rejected and discredited by them for years, with all my formal complaints ignored.  Along with the times I have been involved with their services causing me more distress and almost driving me to suicide several times with unprofessional incompetent behaviour.    Many times I have been taken to the police station for a welfare concerns only to have mental health walk away, the first time this happened was one of the worst experiences of my life -because I had been forced to strip naked.
I phoned ACC yet again on the number you gave me and asked them for a letter explaining to you  I won two reviews in 2010/11 and ACC had not found me any health provider to reinstate my care, even though it is required by law.
As I have already advised you I have talked with the property manager/landlord and they refuse to do anything about the unsafe cladding or derelict shed on the property – I am not lying, I can send you the emails if you like.   I am to unwell and terrified to approach the Tenancy tribunal as last time I did that I was given three months notice and forced to leave – it was very traumatic as I was very unwell at the time and still had my children at home.   In fact given the excessive numbers of times I have been forced to move due to house sales, abusive flatmates and/or poverty have created an extreme fear of moving.   They already want me to move out so they can repair those things and rent the house out for even more money – but of course they could not provide me with a home that cost less or the same as where I do now.  You also know WINZ don’t fully compensate tenants on invalids benefit when their rents go up.
The last person I phoned was the complaints department at the DHB, once I was able to establish what you meant by putting the DHB main number on your letter.   The woman was very nice and is going to do some investigation into everything I told her, which you also know about.
You say you will connect me with services but that is what Tina and Richard were trying to do and you withdrew it all.    The other services you suggest don’t provide services to me, they do it for other people I know but not for me – you know that already.  You told me I should get a lawyer if I have problems with ACC, but I have tried many times and cannot, I have letters from the Law Society and lawyer Susie Barnes to that effect if you would like a copy.
I took your letter as an extremely serious threat to restrict my access to WINZ and have my Invalids benefit reduced or removed, if I couldn’t stop the extreme despair and distress I get into because of the communication impairments related to my disability.  I will consider how to deal with this over the next few days.   The government are calling for submissions on the United Nations Disability treaty, your letter will be a good example of how people with disabilities like mine are treated by our government.   Which is particularly disturbing in the region No 1 in NZ for suicide and No 1 in OECD and NZ for self-harm, you would imagine people in social agencies are aware of the fragility of traumatised disabled victims of violence, inhuman living situations and criminal neglect.
With regards to the imagined ‘distress’ of other people forced to use WINZ to survive, last time I protested outside your office and you called the police, several people seen me and approached me in the days following, saying how they supported what I was doing and hugged me.  They told me them and other friends felt exactly the same but were to scared to say anything.  Are you not aware 80% of the people forced to deal with WINZ feel exactly the same as I do but just aren’t as unwell as me and don’t say anything.  You must know of people who no longer receive a benefit because they committed suicide due to poverty, ongoing violence and unemployment.  You must know WINZ is extremely degrading and people are terrified of you and your organisation.
Thank you for your letter, it will be useful.
Sincerely
Jayne R
Civil Society Activist
HUMAN SEWAGE
————————————————————————–

From: Jayne R
Sent: Wednesday, 28 August 2019 3:55 PM
To: Michele Eades <michele.eades001@msd.govt.nz>
Subject: More information

Ms Eades,
Your letter implies multiple times I am some sort of threat to people’s safety which is extremely offensive and bigoted.   I have never committed violence against any person, they have committed violence against me. I have never be arrested or prosecuted by police for violence or threatening violence, however I have made formal complaints about police for violence and threatening sexual violence against me for my legal non-violent protests.
When a person is so terrorised and distressed because of the inhuman dangerous living situation they have no choice,  are told repeatedly it is their fault, that is when they self-harm, violence towards others is related to uneducated psychotic people believing it is other people who cause their suffering.   Your letter implies my situation is my fault and I have choices, which forces me to self-harm to cope – I know for a fact I have no choices and being subjected to criminal negligence and human rights abuses by health, ACC, welfare and justice organisations and staff.
Sincerely
Jayne R
CSA
HUMAN SEWAGE

From: Jayne R>
Sent: Wednesday, 28 August 2019 8:41 PM
To: Michele Eades <michele.eades001@msd.govt.nz>
Subject: And yet more information and an Official Information Act request

Ms Eades
I did say something about how bad I was feeling when I was forced to go in and fill out the forms you demanded.   I said if I couldn’t work I would rather be dead, which is the way most suicidal impoverished unemployed unwell victims of crime and neglect feel who are deprived of professional health care by ACC.   Me verbalising that actually makes people feel better, not worse – having it validated that other people feel as badly as you do is a comfort, not trauma.   Ignoring how bad people feel who are being forced to beg for shelter and food is what drives people to suicide, self-harm, violence etc.
Tina knew how distressing and deeply humiliating begging for money in front of people at WINZ was for me, she kindly and appropriately accommodated my disability and didn’t force me to go through something so degrading when I was so unwell and highly suicidal.   The act of being forced to publicly beg for money when I would be capable of earning my own money if I had the professional health care, welfare and justice I am entitled to, is what most makes me so desperate to end my life.  Because I know there is absolutely no hope for my future, or anybody like me after 17 years of asking for the health care I am entitled to and need so I can return to work.
I would also point out if anything I said was an act of rebellion, against your degrading, unjust, unprofessional, insulting treatment, under the NZ Bill of Rights I am allowed by law to protest inside a public building.  I have won a significant court case to that effect a few years ago for a protest I did inside Police Headquarters in Wellington.   Sending threats of treating me in a punitive way compared with other people on Supported Living Payment because of my disability and me verbalising how much I disagreed with the way I was being treated is illegal.  It is again a violation of the Bill of Rights and also civil, human and disabled rights under NZ constitutional laws, along with ratified United Nations treaties.   As the Manager of WINZ in the Wairarapa you should know the law in this area.
Under the Official Information Act can you please provide copies of all the MSD/public servant rules laws and regulations you based your letter on.  Please send in paper copy to 29 Clifton Avenue, Carterton within 28 days as required.  I am particularly trying to understand the reasoning behind your anger (rather than compassion) at me self-harming – which is a very distressing/humiliating part of my disorder and an aspect ACC, mental health services, police, politicians and others are happy to incite and leave untreated.  I don’t understand why you demand I don’t do it – what you and other government agencies cruelly do or don’t do to me and others causes it.  Again I would remind you Wairarapa has the highest rate of self-harm and eating disorders in NZ and the OECD.
Sincerely
Jayne R
CSA
HUMAN SEWAGE

From: Jayne R
Sent: Wednesday, 28 August 2019 8:55 PM
To: Michele Eades <michele.eades001@msd.govt.nz>
Subject: Why did you send a letter by mail rather than respond by email?

Ms Eades,
Can you please explain why you sent your distressing letter via the post and not email?  You are well aware one of the most debilitating and difficult impairments involves serious issues opening being able to open my mail and the chances of me seeing the letter were remote??
This is an impairment related to my disability and documented by mental health professionals in past psychiatric reports as well as the two ACC reviews I won in 2010 and 2011 to have my ACC care reinstated.  You have copies of these documents.
Jayne Routhan
—–MICHELE REFUSED TO ANSWER SO SENT IT TO HER SELF-RIGHTEOUS BIGOT BOSS THE HATRED OF DISABLED POOR ABUSE VICTIMS COMES FROM THE VERY TOP PEOPLE COMPLETELY OUT OF TOUCH WITH REALITY – I ALREADY KNEW THAT

From: Jayne R
Sent: Sunday, 1 September 2019 12:30 PM
To: Michele Eades <michele.eades001@msd.govt.nz>
Subject: Official Information Act request and Privacy Act request for copy of my WINZ/MSD file

Under the Official Information Act can you please advise if APM workbroking services ever contracted to Masterton WINZ?

Would they have been the organisation that insulted, patronised and terrorised a mentally ill woman I know about 18 months ago?

Please provide this information urgently as her experience will need to be reported to the Chief Coroner investigating the Bremner murders last year.  Where an APM workbroker told murderer Ross Bremner she would be doing a report to WINZ and he would lose his benefit.
You will be pleased to know I had a very good meeting with one of NZs leading (most influential) psychiatrists last week, I’m sure you’ll be hearing more in regards to it.  I showed him your letter as proof of just how bad things were in Wairarapa.   He has a lot to do with mental health legislation and service provision, also how government organisations (public and private) deal with disabled suicidal people.
Under the Privacy Act can I please have a copy of my MSD file.  I know you have sent this previously but I was very unwell recently and burnt a lot of the papers in my spare room out of despair and hopelessness that anybody would ever help me or stop what was happening to me.
Sincerely
Jayne
CSA
HUMAN SEWAGE
—————————————————————————————————
Note: They have left significant information and documents out of the file I was sent.

From: Jayne R
Sent: Tuesday, 17 September 2019 6:15 AM
To: Michele Eades <michele.eades001@msd.govt.nz>
Subject: I am very frightened I feel like you are going to take my invalids benefit off me

I am going to try and come in, there is a letter here I can’t open and even though your letter of 21 August 2019 has been extremely distressing and I am completely terrified I will come in today.  It is 4.30am, I havn’t been able to sleep all night I am so terrified of going into your office.
I phoned all those people you said, all of them refused to accept the impairments related to my disability about being too terrified to go to a doctor after four years ago being told if I got upset I would never be able to see a doctor ever again.  I only cry, rock and tick – I never did anything, I never hurt anybody, I don’t understand why the doctor and WINZ are doing this.   You know ACC are required by law to reinstate my care, you have the forms about the TWO ACC REVIEWS I WON nine years ago.  I don’t understand why you are doing this to me – I didn’t do anything to you.
Being forced to rot on welfare is not support, it is a cruel and degrading nightmare of hell I have been subjected to for over a decade – because ACC refuse to reinstate my care as a Victim of sexual abuse.  Jacinda Ardern and the Labour party keep saying on the news that they care about sexual abuse, why are they doing this to me, why are you doing this to me.
You never responded to the previous emails I sent you, why not?   You even said in your letter you knew that I couldn’t correspond by letter and preferred email due to my communication impairments.  Why do you send a letter???  I don’t understand.
You have done exactly what the doctor did when I didn’t do ANYTHING TO THREATEN YOU OR ANYBODY ELSE IN ANY WAY.    As I have said before people have told me they are not distressed by me being distressed, they find it comforting that someone else is expressing how they truly feel.
You didn’t tell me what I said that was abusive.
You do not treat me with respect or accommodate my disability, you treated me like a child and abused me for ticking, shaking, crying and self-harming to cope with how humiliating and degrading being forced to live off WINZ is after this many years.   Please explain how does an extremely unwell terrorised disabled mentally injured sexual abuse and criminal neglect victim act in situations that make her want to kill herself.   If ACC reinstated my care like they are supposed to by law, then I would be able to heal and return to work.
Public mental health services are not only abusive to people with Complex PTSD, they also do not accommodate communication impairments and phobias I have developed after this many years being denied professional health care and rotting terrified in poverty in the community with the highest rate of suicide and self-harm in New Zealand.   It is like that because of the appalling behaviour of people just like you Michele, you treat me like I am human sewage – Tina never did – but you took her away and made her life difficult for trying to get my ACC care reinstated.
You tell me there are standards of behaviour – but I have a stress disorder, being overwhelmed and terrified of having to beg to WINZ to survive because ACC are illegally refusing to reinstate my care and mental health services have refused me all services for many years and continue to do so because I am so phobic of doctors.  I tried to ask someone who is an advocate recently but she expected me to (I had to remove a couple of sentences for my safety).   I don’t understand?
You tell me to seek support for my extremely serious mental health issues (60% mortality rate for people with Complex PTSD), but I have done that many many times only to be either refused or the services are so bad they do their best to drive you to suicide with their unprofessional criminally negligent behaviour.  THAT IS WHY WAIRARAPA IS NO 1 IN NZ FOR SUICIDE AND SELF-HARM.  That is why all people who are not junkies/addicts/alcoholics and gamblers get no services.
I can’t manage my life, I live in continual fear of sexual and physical violence EVERY DAY after threats from a Sth African police officer.   I live in continual terror of having to leave where I am living and being homeless and destitute having to give away all my things – so I have absolutely nothing.   I DON’T WANT TO BE IN THIS SITUATION I DON’T WANT TO HAVE NOTHING, I DON’T WANT TO DIE, I DON’T WANT TO BE RAPED AGAIN, I DON’T WANT A MENTALLY ILL FLATMATE TO STEAL FROM ME ANY MORE, I DONT’ WANT TO HAVE TO LIVE WITH DANGEROUS PEOPLE – I DON’T WANT TO HAVE NO FOOD AT THE END OF EVERY WEEK.   Safety. shelter and food insecurity are inhuman in a society where most people have safety, homes and food and know they will in the future – I don’t.   I was too terrified to go to the local food bank after the past two times they were incredibly degrading and insulting – demanding I pick up the food I ordered and how dare I suggest they deliver it.
I didn’t suggest they deliver it at all, I just told them the truth about being so unwell and degraded by having to beg for food – rather than have the health care I was supposed to so I could return to work – that I couldn’t make myself do it.  I know how much those people gossip about the losers, bludgers and junkies they have to give food to in Carterton.
Then they phoned me every day for three days demanding I come and pick up the food parcel I said I needed – even though I told them on two answerphone messages and in an email I was unable to collect it.  It was extremely distressing and made things much worse – just like you know your letter made it much more difficult and terrifying to come into WINZ.  I am sure you would know this – that is why you did it.
I can’t go to the doctor because I have no mental health services, I can’t get mental health services until I go to the doctor???  I don’t understand???  And I am being forced to see Dr Hunefelt who is a terrible doctor, let me down and did not help me at all, she has depression and can’t cope whatsoever with any sadness or trauma – that is why she rejects me, is that why you reject me too Michele?    I wrote a new song on the weekend, based on Janis Joplin’s Piece of My Heart.  It is dedicated to all the women with power over me and who know my situation that terrorise and harm me who don’t protect me from what the government are doing to the most vulnerable poorest victimised sector of society – abused impoverished women.   You would be shocked at the numbers of women I have begged for help from who either harm me, like you do or just ignore what is going on, even though it is illegal and a crime.
Please find me a boarder, please I am begging you, but please make sure they are going to pay their half, do their half of the chores around the house, don’t bring dangerous people to my house, don’t rip me off, don’t steal from me, don’t take advantage of my impairments (I can’t tell people when they are doing something to rip me off or hurt me – I am so terrified I can’t speak).  It is something to do with being raped in my bed and the continuous line of flatmates (other than my own children) I have been subjected to over the years who have ALL hurt me further (except for one of them who was OK and my disabled friend Richard, but he is dead now – nobody told me he had died and I couldn’t afford to go to the funeral anyway – I can’t afford to go to any funerals, my mother abused me for that a few weeks ago).
I will come in today – I will try not to tick, or shake, or be terrified, or self-harm, I will try not to cry I know how much you hate it and hate me for doing it.  I know you want me to stuff down my terror and how degraded I feel.  It will take me all my concentration to do it so I don’t know if I will be able to speak.  I was going to bring someone I know to support me but he abused me on the weekend for believing in God and using Jesus and the bible to give me hope and keep me alive – hope it is end of days and this nightmare will be all over soon, for all the good poor people of our cruel corrupted illegal neo-liberal societies.
According to him I should take medication because of my insane belief in something spiritual.  This from a man who, without medication, suffers dangerous psychosis and paranoia.  (I can’t put the following paragraph on social media).
I am so scared coming in today, I know how much you HATE and DESPISE me for being so unwell and being terrified of degrading welfare and abusive health services for poor people with mental health issues in Wairarapa.  When I think of it become extremely nauseous and have to be sick, when I think of it I become terrified of you, of WINZ of that cruel hate filled elitist letter you wrote to threaten me.   I don’t understand why I’m not allowed to have my ACC care????  I won two reviews nine years ago, then I could get professional treatment care rehabilitation and a home to live in – which is what the law says.   I wouldn’t have to come into WINZ, I could earn my own money and I would never ever have to see you EVER AGAIN and you would never ever have to see me ever again either – which I know we would both be extremely happy about.
WINZ isn’t help when the government are the ones denying the health care etc you are entitled to under law – WINZ is a degrading nightmare of psychological torture and abuse.   I don’t know any person, except rich old people, who are forced to rely on WINZ to survive that like going there.  They all hate it, they all do everything they can to avoid begging for help (and mostly being rejected) from WINZ because of the pleasure many of your staff – especially women – get out of having power over people they consider inferior to themselves.
I am terrified of coming in today after what happened last time and the terrifying letter you sent demanding I don’t upset you for terrorising me?   I don’t understand, I really don’t, I think I do but then things become extremely bizarre and I’m told I’m insane for protesting about not getting my ACC care back after winning two reviews nine years ago.  Why would they do that to an intelligent victim of sexual abuse like me – I don’t understand at all – not when Jacinda Ardern and the Labour party are going on and on and on about the sexual assault of one (several) of their members.  They’re having enquiries and giving every impression the government cares about victims of sexual violence – when it is quite obvious from your letter and the way everybody is pretending ACC don’t owe me that care that they don’t care about sexual abuse victims at all?????   I don’t understand???
Why are you doing this to me Michele, why do you hate me, why are you persecuting and terrorising me for being real and truthful about how bad living in this country after 35 years of austerity against poor people that gets worse and worse every day – because landlords keep putting up rents so we can’t live?????   I don’t understand, I have never hurt you, are you humiliated perhaps, feel guilty perhaps???  I dont’ understand, my girls turned out great, they both now own their own homes – I did my best, despite how abusive ACC, MH and CYFS were to protect them from the world and my dysfunction – I still do.
I am so scared, you are going to hurt me again, you always hurt me, you hurt everybody who goes to WINZ.  You all pretend you care about people, but you don’t, you hate us, that is how you make me feel every time I go.   Tina Hemi was the only person who ever made me feel someone like me should get help, someone who doesn’t steal, doesn’t lie, is a victim of crime, doesn’t do drugs, doesn’t drink alcohol, doesn’t gamble.   What I don’t understand is why people in churches only want to exploit, humiliate and use me to support people who have everything they could ever need.  Or why they demand I help other people when I have nothing, no money and nothing left to give emotionally.  I learnt a long time ago you don’t help other people unless you truly believe they would help you – because all that happens is they suck you dry of everything and you want to die.
I wish with all my heart I didn’t have to go and beg you for help today, there are so many artistic things and ideas I have to support myself but of course no services and no money to do them.
I’m coming in today – I really think I am going to be too terrified to speak and after your threats I will do my absolutely best not to move or cry.  I will bring a note I write now, before I get there, because I don’t know if I will be able to function with my small motor skills in order to sign the form, or write more notes properly.
Have I said anything in this letter that violates any of the rules you demanded in your letter of 21 August 2019.  I am doing my best to manage my disability, I am sorry it makes you feel so bad and so full of hatred and bigotry towards me.   I don’t understand it either, I don’t understand any of this, I only understand what I know to be true and just.  I only understand what the law says you must do, I only understand what the United Nations, our culture and constitution say you must do, I only understand from the perspective of a middle class person who always worked, now thrown on the scrap heap and not allowed to – because I’m not allowed the health care I am entitled to and knowing how abusive, cruel and incompetent health services are.   I don’t understand what happened and how our country got to this point with nobody doing anything to stop it, I don’t understand why this is happening to me, all I want is what the law says, I don’t want to be anywhere near you as much as you don’t want to be anywhere near me Michele.
Its 5.47am I had better get dressed and go – I ended up with more petrol in my car than normal because the $15 limit didn’t work last time I got petrol.  The woman was on the phone inside and didn’t see me waiting, then stuffed it up.  When I realised I had gone over the $15 limit I started to panic, I went inside and started crying, saying I didn’t have $26.22, I was shaking and terrified – if you can’t pay for petrol they get the police to come and arrest you for stealing.  I don’t steal, I don’t lie, I have become so terrorised by poverty I live in a constant state of extreme fear.  If I didn’t have the number of things ACC, MOJ, police, MOH, DHB, HRC, HDC, Ombudsman, currently government MPs, executive (that is you) and judiciary are making sure I have in my life so I can’t cope with ANYTHING – then I would be OK – I would be able to return to work – I wouldn’t have absolutely no hope for the future and I wouldn’t be living in terror.
I don’t THREATEN VIOLENCE towards myself, that is what I am expected to do without professional health care and the necessities of life for a human being in New Zealand.   It would be extremely helpful and less stress for me if I had somewhere stable to stay that I couldn’t be kicked out of and I could have a flatmate so I didn’t have to live on my own.   No decent man wants a destitute worthless suicidal piece of human garbage like me, so there is no chance I am going to meet someone that has a house.   The only men in the darklands are rapists and abusers – I don’t want to live with anybody like that as almost a million women every year are.  I don’t want to live with sexual deviants or men who watch violent movies/TV/games and think they’re great.  I don’t want to live with men who are intellectually handicapped and perverts.
I started this email around 3am, I have to go in today or I feel like you are going to stop my benefit and I don’t know why.  I will try not to shake and tick or move at all, I will really really try, I will try and look normal so you feel better about what you are doing to me and other women with mental health issues as a result of abuse and criminal negligence by authorities.  I will try not to shake and be so terrified of you, I will put on Jesus cloak of protection, he will help me through this, he knows how scared I am, he knows what I am up against in this cruel degrading world.  He knows how I feel, he knows why I want to die having to beg for years for help I entitled to by law, he knows how bad things are for me, he knows all things, he sees your letter and the cruelty behind it.
God please help me now, please God if I don’t get WINZ services I will be homeless, they will take almost everything I own and I won’t have anything to do at all.   If I don’t sign this form that makes me feel sooooooooo bad, if I don’t beg for enough money to survive another week – God please protect and guide me and WINZ staff so I am not humiliated for too long in that horrible evil building, that horrible evil place where the government throw their victims of crime who don’t get over it in the allotted amount of time (which is perfect for rich affluent women and those with supportive families).
God please, I know I don’t believe in you enough, I know I should believe everything will work out, but after 17 years of things only ever getting worse I know you have done your best and it must be end of days.  It must be when good people who care about the poor and their fellow man are persecuted for asking for what they and others are entitled to by law.  God please let me die, please just let me die, P and M are better off without me, I can’t be a burden on them or they will end up where I am.  My brother said its best if I kill myself and so did my mother, I totally agree God, please take me, please give me cancer or something, please I am begging you I would much rather be dead than live in this nightmare of fear and hopelessness for human sewage like me.  Please God, please take me where I won’t hurt any more, where I won’t be made to feel bad every day, where I won’t be degraded to despised to terrorised for telling the truth and asking for what I am entitled to by law.  Please God take me where everybody tells the truth and everybody sticks to the rules.   Please God please
Sincerely
Jayne
HUMAN SEWAGE
——————————————————————————
From: Jayne R
Sent: Saturday, 21 September 2019 2:11 PM
To: Michele Eades <michele.eades001@msd.govt.nz>
Subject: Some important academic information I just found on youtube – I’m sure you are aware of it but I wasn’t until now

Michele,
What you are doing to me is a crime, what you are allowing to be done to me is also a crime, the sort of information below helps me piece together your contemptable criminal behaviour.   Although I don’t understand where me being illegally refused ACC care after winning two court cases so I can recover from the rape/setback comes into neo-liberalism/elitism George is talking about?  I understand about profiting and creating jobs from the persecution/impoverishment/threats of homelessness and food insecurity with neo-liberalism, but not why very powerful people demand I don’t get my ACC care reinstated and don’t get a legal aid lawyer to make that happen.  Why do police and ministry of justice demand my benefit be removed until I attend court – when at the time I was being refused a lawyer and was to unwell to represent myself.
It makes your letter about me being denied invalids benefit because of the self-harm and distress I am in very disturbing – because you must be aware why I am like this and do nothing to insure I do get the necessities of life.   The rape and not guilty verdict were the catalyst, the criminal neglect and being deprived of safe stable affordable housing, treatment care and rehabilitation I am entitled to under ACC and other laws that is why I ended up like this.
I know there is nothing wrong with my brain, I’m intelligent, terrorised and well educated – there is something wrong with the brains of people who continue to deprive me (and other vulnerable abuse victims) of what the law says I am entitled to when they know it is based on a global failure of an economic theory called neo-liberalism.  Wish my father was still alive, he knew and nobody believed him either, it killed him in the end – both the impacts on his small business/ability to make enough to support himself and mum, as well as the cuts to health care for poor people (in order to drive people to buy health insurance).
Hopefully none of the words I have used are going to trigger your threats of not being allowed to communicate with WINZ and lose my invalids benefit.   I call you contemptable and a criminal because you are, I know the laws public servants are required to abide by and I know for a fact you don’t do it.   One day we might be on the same team against those who harm all us peasants to keep their power, land and money.
(LINK to George Monbiot youtube video, didn’t include here, its on other pages)
Jayne R
——————————————————————————————-
LETTER FROM EADES BOSS – BRUNT – I CAN’T COPY TO DOWNLOAD SO WILL HAVE TO TYPE

Ministry of Social Development

 

Jayne R

jr@hotmail

Tena koe Jayne R

 

Thank you for your emails dated 28 August 2019 and 1 September 2019 addressed to Michele Eades, Service Centre Manager, Work and Income Masterton, regarding the letter that was sent to you on 21 August 2019. Your email have been referred to National Office for response.

 

At the outset I must say that I do appreciate the distress you experienced upon receiving the letter. I can assure you that it was not sent with the intention to threaten you or cause distress, but to outline the standards and behaviours that Work and Income expects from people who use its services and visit Service Centres. Your behaviour has been very upsetting to both staff and other people in the Service Centre and it was considered that this needed to be brought formally to your attention. You need to be aware that your actions can upset others, and if this happens again you will be asked to leave the Service Centre until you calm down. The letter does not have anything to do with your eligibility to receive a benefit.

 

The Ministry of Social Development (the Ministry) has made a concerted effort to introduce client-centre service culture changes exemplified by the client commitment including front of house changes in selected offices, the online Eligibility Guide and changes to guidelines on benefit suspensions. These changes have been made in consultation with clients who are reacting positively. More information on these changes can be found here: www .msd.govt.nz/about msd and our work/work programmes / service-culture/indext. Html

 

You have asked for a copy of all the rules, laws and regulations that the letter was based on. There are no specific rules, laws and regulations relating to the issuing of such letters, but the Health and Safety at Work Act (HSWA) 2015 requires organisations, such as the Ministry, to consider both physical and psychological harm as a result of conducting its business. That includes harm to both staff and others who might be in the workplace. The following link will take you to the WorkSafe website and the HSWA: https : // worksafe.govt.nz / laws and regulations / acts / hswa /.

 

The HSWA applies not only to businesses, officers and workers, but also to other people who come into the workplace, such as visitors or customers. They also have some health and safety duties to ensure that their actions don’t adversely affect the health and safety of others.

 

The Ministry has a Health and Safety Policy in place for its staff which references zero tolerance to harmful behaviours. A copy of the recently updated Health and Safety Policy is attached for your reference.

 

In your email of 1 September 2019 you ask if APM work broking services have ever been contracted to Work and Income in Masterton. I can confirm that the Ministry does hold a contract with APM for the Central Region, which includes the Masterton Work and Income office.

 

The Work to Wellness programme (run by APM) supports people who have a diagnosed mental health condition through wrap-around case management, to achieve and sustain employment outcomes that align with their individual goals.

 

This programme is available to people who have been assessed as appropriate and referred by Work and Income. Provider identified clients and clients that self-refer to providers for support must be fully assessed by Work and Income before agreement for referral is completed.

 

Once employment is achieved, both the employee and the employer receive post placement support for up to 365 days in a way that meets the needs of the client and employer.

Thank you again for writing. I hope this information is helpful.

Naku iti noa, na

Elisabeth Brunt

General Manager

Ministerial and Executive Services


MY RESPONSE TO THIS CORRUPT DECEITFUL BIGOT – WHO contradicts herself repeatedly, ignores my complaints,  LEAVES OUT ALL THE IMPORTANT INFORMATION AND ANSWERS TO MY QUESTIONS


From: Jayne R
Sent: Thursday, 3 October 2019 11:40 AM
To: Info (MSD) <Info@MSD.govt.nz>
Subject: Re: 20191002 Reply ROUTHAN

Dear Ms Brunt,
That letter is just as insulting. demeaning, fascist and elitist as Michele Eades, answers no questions about me being illegally and purposely left to rot on welfare by ACC, health services and WINZ.   Yet another rich powerful WOMAN inflicting their self-righteous ignorant neo-liberal HATRED onto a poor powerless WOMAN.
As you work directly for Jacinda Ardern can you please pass on the emails I have sent to her, including links to my youtube channel and website explaining what very powerful, very corrupt, psychopathic/sociopathic, cruel immoral people in our government are not doing what the law says and terrorising people like myself.  She is the Minister of the Arts, I have written to her about having my art censored and being violently assaulted by police for it – for asking for my ACC care to be reinstated after winning two reviews in 2010 and 2011.
It must be getting very uncomfortable for your organisation as neo-liberals, to contain those of us who are now well educated and informed about the form of economic violence and terrorism you operate and promote – ie celebrate making the rich richer and working out ways to oppress and exploit the disabled terrorised poor.
You are dealing with someone who knows what is happening to them is illegal, corrupt, cruel, abusive and oppressive.  Have you even read the legislation you refer to about KEEPING YOUR STAFF SAFE – obviously not.  I am not going to waste my time describing the HATRED and DEMEANING CRUELTY you purposely subject disabled, unemployed, underemployed poor people to on a daily basis – I LIVE THAT NIGHTMARE!
I am truly thankful for those world leading academics like George Monbiot, Chris Hedges, Prof David Harvey, Richard Woolf and artists like Lee Camp etc for validating what is happening to me and explaining why.   Except for the part where I am illegally denied ACC care, I don’t see how that is part of neo-liberalism – except of course I know for a fact ACC are illegally limiting treatment care rehabilitation and housing entitlements to mentally injured victims of crime – mostly women.  I will refer you to my website at www.jrmurphypoet.com and my youtube channel  JR Murphy Poet where I will be responding to your deluded, deceitful elitist bigotry.
Because of my intelligence and education I can explain to you why women who have all their needs met respond to women like myself the way you have.   In a terrorised feudal society as we now have, you have to reject what I am saying in order to keep your belief in the world as being safe and just place – when IT IS NOT.  This is especially important to women like you because that is YOUR FAULT – NOT MINE.  I spend almost all my waking hours educating myself and trying to work out how I can stop you from doing the most EVIL things you do – like handing over housing for disabled and poor to private enterprise (that includes the worst of the worst – charities and not-for-profits like Trust House).
You don’t want the people at WINZ to see the distress you cause people like myself, because it distresses them – AS IT SHOULD – these people are human beings.  Using medications to drug people terrorised by poverty, years of austerity, demeaning welfare hatred, unemployment, domestic violence and shelter and food insecurity is deeply disturbing ILLEGAL behaviour.  Profiting from and exploiting the suffering of people like myself after years of neo-liberal governments like yours shows you are the ones who are insane and corrupt and cruel and criminals – NOT ME.
To you Elisabeth and those who work for ministerial services, I know the law, I know the NZ constitution, I know what I am entitled to, I know what I need, I know my disability, I know the science, I know the politics, I know how corrupted it has become by handing over government responsibilities to uncivilised, issue ridden, unprofessional, greedy people in private enterprise and charities/not-for-profits.   I also know I am a good person on a mission from God with Jesus as my guide, I know the role of artists in a cruel society and I know how abusers of power oppress and discredit artists like myself.  Although if I had the treatment care rehabilitation and safe home I am entitled to under NZ law then I probably wouldn’t be an artist, as my creativity is related to living under inhuman, unsafe conditions without the necessities of life.
You would be very pleased to hear I am now estranged from most of my family who believe – as you obviously do – that I don’t want to work and if my life is so bad I should kill myself.  Thankfully my children are intelligent and I keep them informed as much as I can – without traumatising them, something that people like myself find very hard to do as they don’t have the intelligence, knowledge and spiritual fortitude of faith I do – so pass their trauma onto their children.   Which of course you already know as you market extensively about ‘getting children out of poverty’ by turning them against their PURPOSELY IMPOVERISHED DISABLED PARENTS!
I am both ashamed and disgusted by your response – and am quite sure you would have been one of those withholding details of the sexual abuse of that young woman in the Labour party!   Its time to face up to the fascism and oppression of people with mental health issues as a result of violence and sexual abuse you created Elisabeth, time to face up to it, acknowledge it, admit it and do what is required under New Zealand constitutional laws and signed contract treaties with the United Nations.  Do what the Germans did to those they oppressed – which includes compensation so the resources illegally taken from us are restored and they get to lead a decent life in a civilised society.
We are not a corporation we are a country, you are not a corporation you are a government, the ONLY REASON we have government and law is to keep the peace between rich and poor – I am sure you know that piece of legislation from the Imperial Laws Application Act.   I am sure you will know those part of the Magna Carta that are still legal enactments in this country – ie you are not allowed to destroy people like me, you are not allowed to lie about me and you must give me access to right and justice -WHICH OF COURSE YOU DO NOT.
I should also probably point out that if the bible is true and it is end of days and as I expect I am one of those women sent to test society – then you have completely and utterly failed the test and will be removed from your position of power and punished for what you are doing to me and others.  Noting – if you are gay or HATE Christians for some reason please don’t take your bigotry out on me for my beliefs!  Also everything cruel and corrupt you get police, justice, welfare and health workers to do to me discredits and disempowers you.  You can fool some of the people all of the time and most of the people some of the time – but you can’t fool all of the people all of the time!!!  Not my words, some other intelligent educated person from history.
Please pass onto your ‘goons’ there is no point in hurting me, if it isn’t me it will be someone else, everybody knows neo-liberalism is a failure and has caused extensive cruelty and corruption within our society.  I am a good person, I have never hurt anybody, they hurt me – you hurt me.  This is your job, you go home every night and forget about it, using the extreme amount of money you earn to make your life so wonderful.  This is my life, I have no home and no money and that is YOUR FAULT – NOT MINE!
NOTE: I am currently arranging for an exhibition of my work and that of other terrorised poor who are suicidal and self-harm.  It will not be open to the public because they have suffered enough and do not need to be traumatised more by our criminal neo-liberal terrorist government.   Entry to the exhibition will be by invitation and limited to those who are directly responsible for purposely driving us to suicide, self-harm (and many to violence).  This will include include you, your office staff, Michele Eades and of course Jacinda Ardern to name but a few.  Wairarapa being NO 1 in NZ for driving people to suicide and so close to Wellington there will be no excuses for refusing to confront the harm you cause to society – you drive children to suicide better than any other western country ON THE PLANET.  Time you stopped.   Please refer to my website for all the solutions you should be applying RIGHT NOW and please inform Jacinda Ardern of this exhibition, who I am, details of my website and youtube channel, what I do and what is happening to me.
Sincerely
Jayne R
UN Civil Society Activist
HUMAN SEWAGE
——————————————————————————

From: Jayne R
Sent: Friday, 4 October 2019 5:29 AM
To: Info (MSD) <Info@MSD.govt.nz>
Subject: Re: 20191002 Reply ROUTHAN – Ms Brunt has quoted Worksafe and HSWA without OBVIOUSLY READING IT

Ms Brunt,
I have reviewed the Worksfae HSWA link you gave me, which you OBVIOUSLY HAVE NOT READ, I would point out YOUR RESPONSIBILITY TO ENSURE MY SAFETY.  Given I am the disabled person rotting on welfare for years, thanks to ACC illegally refusing to provide and then reinstate the care I am entitled to under NEW ZEALAND LAW, it would be expected that I am the one who deserves protection under the law you threw in my face to justify your horrendous actions.
Everyone is responsible 

HSWA ensures that everyone has a role to play and makes everyone’s responsibilities clear:

  • Businesses have the primary responsibility for the health and safety of their workers and any other workers they influence or direct. They are also responsible for the health and safety of people at risk from the work of their business.
  • Officers (company directors, partners, board members, chief executives) must do due diligence to make sure the business understands and is meeting its health and safety responsibilities.
  • Workers must take reasonable care for their own health and safety and that their actions don’t adversely affect the health and safety of others. They must also follow any reasonable health and safety instruction given to them by the business and cooperate with any reasonable business policy or procedure relating to health and safety in the workplace.
  • Other people who come into the workplace, such as visitors or customers, also have some health and safety duties to ensure that their actions don’t adversely affect the health and safety of others.
I am the person who is being demeaned and oppressed by the work you do.
Officers such as yourself, given your extremely powerful position, know for a fact ACC are illegally withholding me services and the police are persecuting me for protesting about not getting those services.  You know this because you get your staff to call the police to come and terrorise me for my legal non-violent completely distraught protests about what you are omitting to do under the law in my regard.  You also comply with corrupt police and Ministry of Justice staff who threaten to have all my invalids benefit removed because I LEGALLY AND RIGHTFULLY UNDER MAGNA CARTA refuse to attend court because I am illegally being denied Legal Aid and legal representation.
Recent news reports have exposed how MSD workbrokers were responsible driving a terrified and terrorised mentally ill man to murderer and suicide of his mother and two others after telling him his benefit would be removed.  When I was threatened (oppressed) with having all my invalids benefit removed and got the email in the middle of the night, I didn’t kill myself as I so desperately wanted to end my life, instead I went protesting at 3am in the morning I was outside Masterton District Court with my signs, mostly curled up in a ball crying and rocking backwards and forwards deeply distressed on the steps.  Waiting for them to open so I could get the letter I needed to give to WINZ to say I had attended court and not to remove my benefit.
Just a reminder to you what removing my invalids benefit would do – firstly I would not be able to pay my rent and would be made homeless, I have never in my life not paid my rent and to not pay would mean I would FOREVER have a black mark on my name and have an even lesser chance of EVER getting another rental – considering the extreme and illegal lack of housing in New Zealand for disabled and poor people.   I would lose most of my furniture, art, household items, sentimental items etc that I have had for many years – I don’t have much and most of them were given to me (as I have been rotting on welfare for so long thanks to ACC).  It is almost guaranteed if I did get somewhere to live it would be with an abusive dangerous thieving mentally ill person, as from years of personal experience that is all I get when I try and find a flatmate to share costs and responsibilities of living in a rental property.
That you have misquoted a piece of law to validate your illegal, corrupt, cruel, insulting, demeaning, oppressive, terrifying, criminal, psychological torture of a disabled mentally injured sexual abuse victim is deeply disturbing behaviour from a WOMAN as powerful as yourself.   I can’t imagine the qualifications and experience it takes to get to as powerful position as you have but obviously knowledge of the law and rights of disabled people aren’t on the list!
My self-harm behaviour is a direct result of your staff telling me they would help sort out getting the ACC care I am entitled to under law and getting the police to stop terrorising me for my LEGAL NON-VIOLENT protests about this most grievous situation – then having corrupt senior management staff STOP THE MEETINGS THOSE WINZ STAFF WHO ACTUALLY ARE HUMAN AND ARE CONCERNED FOR MY WELFARE were organising.  Stopped the meetings from happening but didn’t tell me, just left me waiting and hoping after all these years I would get the ACC care I desperately need and am entitled to after winning two ACC reviews in 2010/11.
Understandably my awesome Case Manager Tina Hemi was distraught and being caused psychological harm herself by being prevented from doing what she had promised – after writing AWAITING TREATMENT on my forms and hearing the extreme distress and ongoing harmful situations I was being exposed to as a disabled poor sexual abuse victim in our cruel violent abusive society.  I am sure if Tina (and Richard Fry) knew the law and didn’t fear for her job, she would make her own complaint to Worksafe under HSWA.   Have you advised Tina and Richard their rights in this regard – because I know both of them were distraught being shut down and made into liars by you and your management staff.  Abusers of power like yourself always ‘gaslight’ their victim with lies and half-truths, making them think they are the bad ones.  Years of study and personal experience have made me acutely aware of how this is done – feel free to refer to Prof Philip Zimbardo (I am the person in the cupboard if you are referring to the Stanford Prison Experiment).  YOu should also review the Milgram Experiment and be assured from someone who knows, you are one of the 60% of people who would kill someone on encouragement from someone who said they were a ‘professional’ (eg in a white coat – was it a psychiatrist perhaps?)
Now I have further expressed myself and responded to your horrendous inaccurate abusive letter I will add it to my UN complaint and advise as many people as I possibly can about what is happening.  I have to go through this psychological torture/abuse just to get the ACC care I am entitled to and desperately need – please advise me why this is again, you must know, because nobody will tell me.  That is a crime under New Zealand law and international law, sadly the attorney-general is grossly corrupt and refuses to allow me to take a case against the government in this regard.  Hopefully one day I will get the lawyer I am entitled to under the NZ constitutional documents and will never have to interact with you, your HATEFUL ABUSIVE OPPRESSIVE ORGANISATION or any of the ignorant bigoted sociopaths in it EVER AGAIN.  Kia kaha and aroha to all the decent people at the cliff face who are harmed by what they see happening to WOMEN TREATED AS HUMAN SEWAGE LIKE ME.
Sincerely
Jayne
Civil Society Activist
HUMAN SEWAGE
——————————————————
NOTE:  While typing out the letter from Brunt I saw several other questions that weren’t answered and her complete rejection of the staff member who said WINZ AREN’T HERE TO FILL YOUR CUPBOARDS – when my friend asked for a food grant she DESPERATELY NEEDED.   I’ll send her another email soon about it and post here.

Michele Eades WINZ Manager Masterton being a corrupt bigot for Labour Party

Have to stop watching and reading news, got to get more of what happening to me on the internet, as that is about as big a news as you can get in the SUICIDE, SEXUAL ABUSE, FREEDOM OF SPEECH, VIOLENCE, GOVERNMENT CORRUPTION, CORRUPT LEGAL SYSTEM CORRUPT HEALTH SYSTEM topics.

Below is a recent letter from Michele Eades, it was posted to me, PURPOSELY NOT EMAILED, because Michele and her chronies know I have issues opening my mail and were hoping I wouldn’t.  Also they know I had started copy and pasting emails to this website and didn’t want this one to go through.   I will show you the letter on my youtube channel so you know it is legitimate.  Also I will start posting all the emails she refers to and the recent one from her boss.  Which referred to legislation on a Worksafe website that she said validates their position about ME CAUSING HARM TO WINZ STAFF and visitors by being terrified, traumatised, distraught and self-harming – I’ve read it – it doesn’t.

Please note these letters are extremely difficult for me to go through and to respond to, it causes me significant distress and usually I have to self-harm to cope and start crying throughout the ordeal.  I desperately need a civil legal aid lawyer, the UN or someone to protect me from this discrimination, oppression and corruption.  If you had someone writing lies and this sort of offensive insulting degrading bigotry- YOU KNOW IS ILLEGAL UNDER NZ DISABILITY AND CONSTITUTIONAL LAWS – you would feel the same as me.

Go to my youtube channel and you will find the video I did AFTER I had been at WINZ, the extremely traumatised state I was in.

WINZ Letterhead – Masterton Service Centre

21 August 2019

Jayne R
…. Ave
Carterton

Dear Jayne

I am writing regarding your visit to the Wairarapa Service Centre in early August and the tone and content of your recent emails.

Your behaviour on 2 August 2019 was very upsetting to other clients in the Service Centre.  I need to be sure that staff, clients and visitors (including you) feel safe in the Service Centre.

When you visit our Service Centre you can expect to be treated with respect and concern for your circumstances.  However, I also need you to treat our team, and other clients and visitors appropriately and with respect.  This will enable us to provide a good service to everyone.

There are standards of behaviour that all clients need to meet when in our Service Centre.  In particularly this includes

  •  No behaviour upsetting to others, including yelling or abuse and
  •  No violence or threats (to yourself or to others)

In the future if you are verbally abusive, or distruptive you will be asked to leave the office until you regain your composure.  We are unable to provide you with a good service when you behave in the way you did on 2 August 2019.  You will be welcome to return to the office when you are composed.

Regardless of the situation, or how upset you are feeling it is not OK to call MSD staff inappropriate or abusive names, either in person or by email.  It is also not appropriate to request me to kill you.  It makes it difficult for us to provide you the service we want to and we cannot tolerate this.

If you email using abusive language we may not be able to continue to correspond with you by email, and instead you will need to either phone our contact centre, use MyMSD or attend appointments in the Service Centre.

I know that you have a number of things that you are managing in your life but would like to remind you that it is important that you seek support for these things from the appropriate experts.  We are not the experts, however, we are happy to facilitate referrals to the agencies if you would like us to do so.

In particular I would like to remind you of the following agencies that are available to support you.

Health: GP – Carterton Medical Centre 06 3798105
Wairarapa DHB:  069469800
Mental Health Services/crisis team 069469805
ACC: 0800101996
Tenancy: direct with landlord or tenancy tribunal

If you email regarding any of the above issues we can only remind you of the support available from these agencies and offer to connect you with them.  I would recommned that you go direct to them regarding your concerns rather than emailing me.

We do want to make sure that you are receiving all the financial assistance you’re entitled to so if you ever wish to apply for addiction assistance or check that you’re receiving what you’re entitled to please contact us.

I know that you prefer to communicate with us by email so hope that you will take this letter seriously and ensure that your language and messages are appropriate so that we can continue to support you.

Yours sincerely

 

Michele Eades
Service Centre Manager

…………………………………………………….

After reading that load of total fkn BULLSHIT, lies and cognitive dissonance it becomes overwhelming because I know how abusive or non-existent the ‘services’ are – I have been rejected and terrorised by them many times.   This is exactly what abusers of power do – they call it gaslighting, the more formal name is cognitive dissonance.   She wrote this letter that appears to be so genuine, sensible and sane – when I know it is not.  This is the words of a radicalised person on the most massive guilt trip about what she personally has done to ensure MY ACC CARE WAS NOT REINSTATED she has to delude herself to cope psychologically.   Even though other WINZ staff were trying to make ACC reinstate my care so I could get off welfare, Michele told me my legal problems were nothing to do with WINZ, it was my problem if I couldn’t get a lawyer or care, the meeting was cancelled.

Another comment I will make before I have to leave my computer and binge and vomit – I am screaming for my ACC care back so I can go back to work, not be unemployed and relying on these revolting people at WINZ (even the good people at WINZ, I don’t want these people in my life!).  ME AND EVERYBODY WHO FORCED TO GO IN THAT BUILDING HATE IT (except for the double dipper old people who work at really good jobs even though they are over 65 and/or get huge amounts of money from their wealth WHILE STILL BLUDGING OFF THE NZ TAXPAYER GETTING A BENEFIT of $100s every week – and free travel).

The things I said loudly as I was leaving was IF I CAN’T WORK I WOULD RATHER BE DEAD x 3  When you understand the context of my distraught behaviour then you would look at this letter just as I do – INSANE DELUDED BULLY JUSTIFYING THEIR UNJUSTIFABLE CRUEL BEHAVIOUR.

Just for a laugh I contacted all the people, except for Tenancy Tribunal on the list Michele gave me – all people who had been refusing me services for years, who did the same again.  Along with blaming me for my worsening terror trying to interact with services that were insulting, degrading, unprofessional and criminally negligent.  I’m not quite sure why these people have gone quite mad – I think it has something to do with those in power putting EVERYBODY who suicidal in the category of spoilt brat, middle class or rich kid with no ‘resilience’.

………………………………………………………….

BELOW ARE THE EMAILS I SENT MICHELE EADES BEFORE HER LETTER ABOVE


From: Jayne R
Sent: Monday, 27 May 2019 9:46 PM
To: Michele Eades <michele.eades001@msd.govt.nz>
Subject: Re: for your information

Hi Michelle,
Since when do I have Ministry of Justice fines?????  Nobody has advised me of anything, are they allowed to take money out of my benefit without advising me?  Are you allowed to take money out of my benefit without advising me.
I can’t afford to pay $15 a week, I have told you repeatedly I cannot live on the money I was getting and certainly can’t do it now you have cut it by $30 – you told me when I first contacted you about the massive increase in my rent that you would change the repayment arrangements for anything I owed, why havn’t you done that.  Please advise what do I owe and who do I owe it to, can you please outline all this money coming out of my weekly benefit.
You know the terrible situation I have been in with flatmates because of impairments related to my disorder, also because I have been illegally put in harmful situations by Corrections and mental health services.  You know I am terrified and how the last person who contacted me about accommodation was a sexual deviant, when I put a notice up on the local supermarket board.  Today I have put a notice on Trade Me, this is the third time this year with no response, although I am terrified I am going to get yet another flatmate who takes advantage of my disability because I am still being illegally denied health care and support I am entitled to.
How can there be a maximum on accommodation supplement when the cost of rentals has gone through the roof.  The government not only are setting rental rates on their tenancy website, they are then not compensating disabled people on welfare who are forced to pay them.  Disabled people like myself who are required by multiple laws to be in state housing living in their communities in culturally appropriate situations.  I have relatives buried in Carterton cemetery, my children were born here, I have owned houses here, this is where I live, this is my community, this is my culture – ugly and cruel as it is now so many racist elitist neo-liberal immigrants live here (that includes immigrants to our region from within NZ) it is my home I belong nowhere else (fact is I don’t even belong here, no disabled human sewage like myself has a place here).  I know someone just moved here paying $400/week for an old small 3 bedroom, everybody on welfare paying less are completely terrified – do you get lists of the number of people you are driving to suicide, violence and addiction every week?
It is very strange you are so keen to pay the landlord even when they refuse to make this property safe as required by law.  Nothing I can do about it, can’t go to the Tenancy Tribunal because if I do I will never get another rental if I have to move.  The thought of moving makes me want to be sick – I don’t ever want to be forced to move again, it is inhuman and shows a complete failure of neo-liberalism and privatisation.
It is deeply distressing and harmful to have these constant forms reminding me what a worthless impoverished piece of garbage I truly am.  Why are there so many things, is it done purposely to terrorise and degrade people, to ensure they have to beg for food regularly so they will kill themselves????  If I don’t get health care, how does anybody expect me to work????  I don’t understand, that is why we have ACC law, to make sure people have all the help possible to return to work and not let injuries, physical or mental, to destroy their lives.   I never got the care I was entitled to and they destroyed my life, that is not only a violation of ACC law, it is a violation of Magna Carta – the founding document of our modern government and Rule of Law.  If government don’t follow the Magna Carta and Westminster Statute then the citizens who being destroyed have every legal right to ignore all laws.
If I can get a flatmate that isn’t going to harm me you can put the debt payments back up, but I definitely can’t pay it now, you are taking food and essentials from me, why are you doing that, what sort of person are you Michelle.  I have never taken food from you, never terrorised you or your family, never stood back and watched you being harmed, so why do you do it to me – I don’t understand.  You are a public servant you are supposed to uphold decency, civil and ethical behaviour, you swore an oath to uphold the law, not to do what corrupt government officials tell you to when you know it is wrong.
Why are you doing this to me, why are you doing this to so many people and hurting them so much they self-harm, suicide and become highly dysfunctional.
Sincerely
Jayne R
( Note fines were parking fines from protesting in Wellington in 2017 – I tried to get the Wellington Council to remove them, they refused – they don’t want poor people bringing their cars to wellington to protest about poverty, abusive mental health services and govt corruption.)
…………………………………………………………..

From: Jayne R
Sent: Wednesday, 29 May 2019 5:19 PM
To: Michele Eades <michele.eades001@msd.govt.nz>
Subject: Letter for Carterton Food Bank

I am required to get a letter from WINZ to access any foodbank, can you please provide that letter that I am now so desperately poor I can’t afford food every week.  What a worthless piece of garbage I am and now even more people in town will know what a disgusting loser I am.  Imagine if I told them I had bulimia.  I just spoke to Carterton Food Bank, told them I was unwell and couldn’t pick it up because of how I self-harm and shake and tick.  I think they going to deliver it.  (They never did – just ignored me.)
They want a letter from you so I don’t have to go through that every week.  I FEEL SO ASHAMED, SO DEGRADED, OH GOD I WANT TO DIE, WHAT A WORTHLESS WORTHLESS WASTE OF AIR, I DON’T BELONG HERE, I DON’T BELONG ANYWHERE.  The woman on the phone hung up on me because I started crying and told her how bad I felt about having to beg for food.  I told them I was developing diabetes, which I am, because of all the carbohydrates I have to eat and asked for veges and meat/fish.  I would help out growing veges somewhere to repay them, because I never know how long I will be at this house and so can’t plan for food all year round.  I always thought growing food would be temporary until I got back to work.
My daughter had a bad car accident and I can’t go to her in Whakatane, I can’t stop crying – how am I supposed to have strong family relationships if I dont’ have any money to visit my family?  Today was my first pay and I couldn’t stop crying about that either.
Saw a documentary not long ago about peasant farmers in Sth America being driven from their land so rich people could build houses.  A gang member who refused $1million to do it said THE TEARS OF THE POOR WILL CATCH UP WITH YOU ONE DAY.  That’s why he refused but other greedy members of the gang did it.  In New Zealand our government do it to us, our neighbours do it to us, you do it to people for a job.  I wonder how many people cry and self-harm because of you Michelle.  We have the highest rate of self-harm in the world in Wairarapa and I am sure that would be related to abusive mental health services and poverty.  I know King Street Artworks trespasses any person who does that – a mental health provider banning some of the most desperate persecuted terrorised people in our community – gross violation of human rights against a person with a disability.  They don’t care of course because King Street is only for mild mentally ill people, not worthless garbage like me.
After 18 months Snr Sgt Jennifer Hansen offered to fill out the legal aid form for me yesterday, she said it on an email and I was in Masterton within 20 mins.   I had told Legal aid I couldn’t fill out the forms and they refused to provide me a lawyer to help me so for 18 months I just get terrorised over and over again.  But then you know ALL ABOUT MY CASE DON’T YOU MICHELLE, you know everything, you just don’t care the government are harming me – which is a criminal act under Sections 150a and 151 of the Crimes Act.
I wonder if I will ever stop crying, if I will ever stop hurting, if my heart won’t be broken forever, if I will ever be safe – after this long being forced to rot on welfare I am sure it will never ever stop.  Never, no hope ever, I wish someone would shoot me, I really do.
human sewage


From: Jayne R
Sent: Friday, 31 May 2019 3:47 PM
To: Michele Eades <michele.eades001@msd.govt.nz>
Subject: Can I please have letter for foodbank?

Can I please have the letter the website requires, I phoned someone from Carterton foodbank a couple of days ago, I got upset and the woman hung up on me.  So I don’t know if I’m going to get any food or not and I really need it.  It makes me really unwell when I have food insecurity, makes my fight flight and freeze response really bad.
I don’t want to beg for food from you, it makes me feel really really bad, really ashamed and worthless.  If I hadn’t been raped and neglected like I was it could have been me in your job, I’m an intelligent person, I even have reports to say that, I don’t understand why you think its OK for ACC and the government to stop me getting health care I am entitled to and force me to beg for food when it is obvious how much this contributes to me wanting to kill myself EVERY SINGLE DAY.
Jill Greathead at the Carterton Council told me foodbanks were for people on welfare who couldn’t afford to live, that is what they were set up for, that is what neo-liberalism required.  I am still extremely distressed about not being able to go and see my daughter who had the car accident, it is her birthday on 3 June.  Her sister just told me her and some friends going up for her birthday, but no room for me to go.  My heart is breaking – how am I supposed to have a supportive family if I’m too poor to go to them when something happens.
If I had the $10,000 ACC are withholding at least I could try and do something to make some money, try and get my art, music and things I make to provide me with enough money to live – so I don’t have to be on welfare when it is sooooooo degrading and abusive in my case.
Jayne
HUMAN SEWAGE


From: Jayne Routhan
Sent: Friday, 31 May 2019 10:58 PM
To: Michele Eades <michele.eades001@msd.govt.nz>
Subject: Proof I am looking for a flatmate, so far nobody has called

I also have it listed on a facebook site, but nobody suitable so far, only a couple of people have inquired.
I was reading the letter you sent demanding I provide proof I am trying to change my circumstances so I am not living in such poverty I want to kill myself.
Was watching the government wellbeing budget and just couldn’t stop crying, what a lie, what an enormous lie – so all rich people will think poor people are getting help.  There is no way back to wellness when you don’t have the necessaries of life and wealthy immigrants are driving you from your homes into worsening and more dangerous situations.  Our government does that on purpose and profits from it, creates jobs out of persecuting poor people.   Do you know what it is like to know definitely that is happening and how illegal and corrupt it is, how many laws it violates and nobody does anything to stop it.
1600 more mental health workers, 1600 more USA trained ignorant issue ridden sociopaths whose only objective is to create money and jobs for drug companies and themselves.  This is never going to end is it Michelle, denying garbage like me health care and keeping us terrorised is going to continue isn’t it.  I bet any new services goes to youth and soldiers – yet again persecuted abused women will miss out – as we always miss out.  Its like I’ve stepped back into the dark ages.
Still don’t understand why you and your bosses HATE me so much they incite me to suicide just for asking for ACC care I’m entitled to – I have to go back to work Michelle or I am going to die.  I can’t stop crying about not being able to go and see my daughter in Whakatane after her car accident, its her birthday, a group of her friends are going up for a party and her sister – there is no room for me.  There are so many people who have died that I cared about and couldn’t afford to go to their funerals.  I don’t understand why you HATE me so much, I really don’t.  I have never hurt you, I never hurt anybody you love, I never stole money from you, I never took your food away, I never took your house away, I never hurt you – why are you hurting me, why are you letting them hurt me.    Please I don’t understand, you must know why they deny me professional health care and yet make such a huge deal about providing mental health services WHEN NOWHERE I CAN FIND THAT I WILL GET ANYTHING I AM SUPPOSED TO HAVE.
Why do people want me dead Michelle, why do they want me unemployed and terrorised, I just want to return to work.  I tried to heal myself, I DID EVERYTHING I COULD POSSIBLY DO, I almost died trying so many times.  I can’t do this on my own and I can’t do this with health people who are insulting patronising and abusive.  That seems to be all you train now, people in the past were OK, but those being trained through our corrupted American neo-liberal controlled universities are REALLY REALLY BAD.
Wellness budget and you know as well as I do, nothing has changed for 99.9% of the people forced to beg for welfare that you HATE/HARM enjoy having to beg.

That is why people kill themselves, because what the media and government say happens is exactly the opposite to what does happen.

Will just keep trying not to kill myself and hold on until amagedon or whatever the bible calls it comes, its soon, lots of people know its soon.  Hopefully I know enough violent people to be reasonably safe from them when the violence erupts here – because it is going to.   Organisations like yours will be targeted I am sure, you are where the degradation and HATRED is inflicted on people.  So much HATE I am subjected to and people wonder why I verbalise hate, why I self-harm, why I’m bulimic, why I can’t cope.
Wish I was dead today, if I can’t work I don’t want to live – nobody does.
HUMAN SEWAGE


From: Jayne R
Sent: Friday, 31 May 2019 11:07 PM
To: Michele Eades <michele.eades001@msd.govt.nz>
Subject: I can’t understand how my wellbeing will be improved from this budget can you please explain how

Its all over the news this budget is about helping suicidal human sewage like me.  Can you please explain how that is going to work in my case, are they going to stop the 3mthly filling out of forms that make me want to kill myself and self-harm.  What happened with you, happened even worse at the police station – I had to get a police woman to fill out the Legal Aid forms because Legal Aid refused me a lawyer and I couldn’t do them myself for past 18 months.
Its a shame as a woman you HATE me because I was raped, sodomised and the person found not guilty, then refused health care, welfare, justice and safe place to live I am entitled to under new Zealand law.  Because I need services and resources a rich/middle class person wouldn’t need in being restored to ‘wellness’ you HATE me, you enjoy watching me beg like the other day, you enjoy me crying and terrified.  I don’t understand why you HATE me Michele I really don’t, you must hate me because you don’t want me to get health care I am supposed to have after winning two court cases nine years ago.  You must HATE all the women forced to beg for welfare, ewwwww.
Did I tell you I phoned for a food parcel but they never came, although I couldn’t wait around all day, by 11.30am I have to go out and see another person or I start self-harming and become bulimic.  Maybe I was away when they came around and they thought I must not have wanted the food if I wasn’t prepared to stay in my house all day waiting.  Or maybe they knew I would be waiting and just didn’t want to bring the food because I was so distraught on the phone????  YOu told me I have no food allowances left, so what am I supposed to do now – do you know how bad ostracized and worthless I feel.
I bet you don’t, I hope one day my tears will catch up with you and those who do this to me and other abuse and trauma victims.
WISH I WAS DEAD WISH I WAS DEAD WISH I WAS DEAD
JR
HUMAN SEWAGE
————————————————————————————————————

From: Jayne R
Sent: Wednesday, 12 June 2019 7:25 PM
To: myjobsearch_wairarapa (WORKANDINCOME) <myjobsearch_wairarapa@workandincome.govt.nz>
Subject: Letter for local food bank – please provide OIA/Privacy Act details that were missing.

I have received the details of the fines, which I email Wellington City Council about and why under Bill of Rights and Magna Carta I should not have to pay them based on protesting about serious legal and social issues, as well as me being MADE PURPOSELY POOR by ACC and the government.

I have not received the information about what all the LOANS are for – I don’t even know what they are for, not only do I want the information for revolting bigots/gossips in the community who enjoy denigrating poor people by making them beg for food, I want if for me UNDER THE OFFICIAL INFORMATION ACT, ARE YOU GOING TO PROVIDE THEM.  I can’t go to the food bank and beg for food until I get them.  I phoned a couple of weeks ago, they said I would get food but nobody turned up, I left messages but nobody returned my call.

If people are going to gossip and spread cruel lies about me, then I’d rather a few of them actually knew what was going on.
Please also advise in writing how long I have been on welfare WAITING FOR TREATMENT I am supposed to have received from ACC nine years ago after winning two reviews.  I would like this information and I want to make sure my community knows what is going on as well.

Do you have all the information about the number of living/flatmate/boarder situations I have been in where I have been ripped off and left extremely traumatised, exploited and even more impoverished.

Sincerely
Jayne R
HUMAN SEWAGE
———————————————————

From: Jayne R
Sent: Tuesday, 2 July 2019 9:37 PM
To: Michele Eades <michele.eades001@msd.govt.nz>
Subject: Complaint and update

Hi Michele,
I havn’t been able to organise everything required to go and beg for food from the local foodbank, I am getting by but my stress disorder is really really bad, having so little food sets off every part of my basic instincts when I have food insecurity.   Not being able to make myself go through the deeply degrading and overwhelming process of providing all that information in order to beg for a weeks food – what I consider INHUMAN AND PSYCHOLOGICAL VIOLENCE!
Also upset when my friend told me her visit to WINZ this week, where she was so broke after not being paid by her small part time job last week because she was sick and unable to phone and tell them she hadn’t worked.   After finally, with all of us encouraging her for the past two years, while around six different health and welfare professionals allowed her to suffer in poverty on disability, she was transferred to the invalids benefit.  When she told me, we both cried on my front porch, she had been to unwell to fight for what she was entitled to, too unwell to go against her doctors rhetoric about GOING ONTO INVALIDS BENEFIT WOULD BE A STEP BACKWARDS!!!!!  A filthy rich pig doctor saying that to a woman with so little and me her friend having to help her when I could, so did others – who were almost as poor.
When she went in, she got someone different – I HATE NEW WINZ STAFF, they usually the most revolting haters.  When she politely said – because she is a proud person and HATES begging for food too – can I please have a food grant I have no food in my cupboards.  The maggot across from her said WE’RE NOT HERE TO FILL YOUR CUPBOARDS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!    We’re not here to fill your cupboards!!!!!!
If WINZ are not there to put food in your cupboards and in your fridge THEN WHY DO THEY EXIST AT ALL.   You wouldn’t understand what it is like and how deeply humiliating it is if people visit you – when you having very little in your cupboards and fridge – I DO – ESPECIALLY AT THE MOMENT.  Rich people like you have friends and family over for a meal I am assuming – you would think that would be part of our Pakeha/Maori culture – SHARING FOOD – like humans have been doing for 10,000s years.  But not in 21st Century New Zealand under the cruellest most corrupt deceitful government I am sure we have ever had.
Please advise me if people aren’t allowed to have ANY FOOD IN RESERVES AT ALL then what happens if their is a regional environmental emergency or something like that??????    She needed $100, but the maggot across from her would only give her $50.  WHEN YOU HAVE NOTHING, YOU ALSO HAVE NO CLEANING SUPPLIES, I cant stop crying.  I have always believed staff are a reflection of management and so far you are definitely that from my experience.  Telling me to get a lawyer rather than Tina and Stephen trying to help me, when my forms say AWAITING TREATMENT for almost 10 years!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Been having problems with the property manager here   (can’t put next three paragraphs in due to fear of eviction).
Last time I went to the tenancy tribunal the advice I was given got me and my kids kicked out of Reading Street when landlord just gave me 3 months notice, which they didn’t have to explain.
Shame I’m too unwell to fight them through the Tenancy Tribunal, if I had my ACC care reinstated I would have that support.  They used to help me with forms and things back then – I dont’ have anybody in my life to do it – I’m surrounded by terrorised disabled poor people, they can barely run their own lives, let alone help me out.  I can’t ask them also because I have become extremely unwell in situations when I have to fill out forms begging for ANYTHING and they would no longer associate with me if they saw that.
WISH I WAS DEAD EVERY SINGLE DAY, SOOOOO WISH I WAS DEAD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Jayne R
HUMAN SEWAGE
————–AFTER I RECEIVED LETTER FROM EADES, NEXT POST HAS EMAILS I SENT

UN Association of New Zealand – corrupt globalists or not? You choose?

Got latest news from UN Association of New Zealand and was incensed considering my situation and what I know.

From: Jayne R
Sent: Tuesday, 1 October 2019 9:26 AM
To: United Nations Association of New Zealand <office@unanz.org.nz>
Subject: Children should be taught in schools about democracy & constitutional law, HOW TO NOT DESTROY THE WORLD ON A GLOBAL SCALE USING THE UN & GLOBAL TRADE

And here is the news from an oppressed disabled Civil Society Actor in New Zealand who has been told by your organisation for years  (and Amnesty) that you don’t deal with individual cases – no matter the levels of violence and injustice.  No matter which group of disabled/persecuted people you belong to and advocate for.  Yet you turn up to have a say in human rights consultations like last year.  YOu were there at Victoria University when they tried to evict me from the meeting for no reason – I got an apology about that from the university.

Since then I have been formally trespassed for being upset with a woman from a quasi govt organisation that decides on the types of work us peasants will be trained for to cater to employers.   Apparently the American running it was wondering why disabled people were not included in employment needs, while the NZ woman who part of that group was an elitist patronising insulting bigot who was happy disabled sexual abuse victims (mostly women)being illegally denied extensive ACC treatment care rehab and SAFE HOME TO LIVE IN then entitled to under law WERE SUFFERING AND KILLING THEMSELVES, having their children taken and forced to live in dangerous situations due to illegal lack of housing – AND DEPRIVED OF WORK THEY CAN DO CONSIDERING THEIR DISABILITIES AND COMMITMENT TO THEIR CHILDREN.

The above is a long sentence I know, can’t be bothered fixing it.   Was watching an excellent youtube video by academic George Monbiot about how GLOBALISATION was the death nell for capitalism because it doesn’t work on a global scale.   Mmmmmm isn’t your organisation the one that promotes global trade above all reason & proof of its destruction.  Aren’t you that part of the United Nations that everybody is working to shut down and stop.  Also National Party MP and your founder John Hayes was my MP in Wairarapa and extremely bigoted, abusive and fascist from my PERSONAL EXPERIENCE of years begging for my ACC care to be provided as required by law.  Wairarapa became No 1 for suicide during his reign of neo-liberal terror. He is also associated with the neo-liberal charity abomination Trust House Wairarapa, where they take from the poor with ‘market’ rents and give to the middle class and rich for sports, arts and business projects.

PLEASE NOTE:  The Oxford (and every other) dictionary definition of CHARITY is giving to people in NEED – not people who have all their needs met and just WANT MORE & MORE & MORE & MORE.    Meaning of the world CHARITY was changed by our corrupt neo-liberal controlled government through the Charities Act – how Orwellian is that.  Changing the meaning of words, go figure!  I’m starting to wonder if neo-liberal terrorists use Orwell’s book 1984 as their manifesto!

Here are the facts and maybe one day – although I very much doubt it – you will actually do something to help me and other victims(mostly women) of domestic/flatmate violence who subject to 80% of the crime in this country.  Neo-liberalism is a failure, housing market is a failure, human rights are a failure, UN is a failure, capitalism is a failure, democracy DOESE NOT EXIST and RULE OF LAW DOESN’T EITHER for us oppressed disabled poor rotting in the darklands of this neo-liberal terrorist hell.

YOu should really check out my facebook page Jayne E Routhan I just started it and first time since I was hurt 17 years ago telling my affluent family what is happening to me.  Its going about as hate filled as you can get.  So far my brother has told me if my life is so hard I should kill myself, then yesterday that I am a violent toxic poison person for telling my family HE HAD TOLD ME TO KILL MYSELF.   Although I am connecting with other ostracised members of the family who understand what happening as well.

Currently up on 23 minor police charges for my LEGAL NON-VIOLENT protests within the rules of UN Civil Society Handbook – which I show the judge at times.  Latest round in years of being charged with minor crimes only to have them dropped or win them, dozens of them since 2002 (after rape & trying to get ACC care I entitled to) Two of these charges relate to a current sitting Labour Party member I am not allowed to name and Bell Gully Compass Health.  One related to a piece of art I blutacked to the Labour party office in Masterton and a poem I put on my website.   Also for throwing red paint on the White ribbon banner in Masterton police station after I was violently assaulted and threatened with rape for protesting that I couldn’t get my ACC care and was phoning them highly suicidal, self-harming, almost psychotic and they had police trying to prosecute me for Misuse of a Telephone for begging to have my care reinstated.  You already know all of this I have contacted you several times before over the past 10 years.

Please respond to this email, advise me why you have refused all these years to interact with me and what you intend to do in the future now you know what is happening to me.  Thank you
I look forward to your urgent reply.
Sincerely
Jayne R
Civil Society Actor
HUMAN SEWAGE

From: United Nations Association of New Zealand <office@unanz.org.nz>
Sent: Monday, 30 September 2019 1:39 PM
To: jrouthan@hotmail.co.nz <jrouthan@hotmail.co.nz>
Subject: September Newsletter United Nations Association (UNA NZ)

Latest from the UN and UNA NZ

 

Latest news from the UN Association of NZ
View this email in your browser
September 2019

Ka nui te mihi kia koutou katoa
Dear Members and Supporters of the United Nations Association

The United Nations is an organisation that serves the world. If there is a problem in one country they try to solve it by negotiation.

The younger generation should be taught in schools about United Nations activities. At the start of UN model assembly, recently held in Hamilton, I asked the High School students, “Have you heard of UNDP?”. They did not know the answer. After giving the answer I ask them, “Who was the first female head of the United Nations Development Program?”. They do not know the answer. I then ask, “Do you know the name of the previous Prime Minister of New Zealand?”. Then they will say, Hon. Helen Clark.

Our topic for this year for Hamilton Model UN, which you can read about further down in this newsletter ,was Climate Change. This is a very hot topic locally and internationally.

On the 27th September, school students are striking from school and university to protest lack of acton on climate change and push for a climate emergency declaration. These students are our future. They are awake to the effects of climate change on their lives. This strike, they are calling for adults to join them.

I come across various students who say to me that they have taken part in the Waikato Model UN Assembly in the past. Students who had won the speech trophy had ended up as solicitors and doctors, doing well in life. One of them had even ended up as Prime Minister.

I will be glad if the New Zealand Government could introduce UN activities into the curriculum of the school education system and our Prime Minister Hon. Jacinda Arden should be able to suggest this since she had won the Waikato branch speech trophy in the past. There is a lot of reason for this request.

You are welcome to forward and share this newsletter with anyone interested in strengthening the work of the United Nations.

Ngā manaakitanga,

Mano Manoharan
Waikato Branch President
United Nations Association of New Zealand

UNA NZ and Family Planning host United Nations Population Fund Executive Director, Dr. Natalia Kanem.
On the 16th September UNA and Family Planning hosted an afternoon discussion with UNFPA Executive Director Dr. Natalia Kanem. 

Dr. Natalia Kanem is the Executive Director of United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA) and the United Nations Under-Secretary-General. Dr. Kanem brings more than 30 years of strategic leadership experience in medicine, public and reproductive health, social justice and philanthropy. Dr. Kanem is among the highest-ranking women at the United Nations and the first Latin American to head the agency. This year marks the 25th anniversary of the International Conference on Population and Development (ICPD) which recognised that reproductive health as well as women’s empowerment and gender equality, are the pathway to sustainable development. How far have we come? What challenges do we face? The discussion was an exciting opportunity to learn more about the direction of the UNFPA and where we need to focus going forward.

Pictured above: Dr Natalia Kanem (centre) Executive Director of UNFPA with Peter Nichol (right – President UNA NZ) & Joy Dunsheath (left – Immediate Past President)

New Zealand Sustainable Development Goals Summit Hosted in Auckland this Month 

On the 2nd September, experts from all sectors addressing New Zealand’s sustainability challenges gathered at the 2019 New Zealand Sustainable Development Goals summit. The theme focused on ‘Accelerated action, together.’.

Victoria Rhodes-Carlin, a member of the steering committee spoke about UN Youths event ‘the Aotearoa Youth Declaration’ that is hosted in Auckland very year and creates the Youth Declaration policy document. The Youth Declaration gives decision makers access to youth perspectives on key issues. Including, many issues encompassed by the SDG’s. Read the Youth Declaration 

A keynote address was given by Helen Clark.

Sophie Handford- National Coordinator for the climate strike shared a youth perspective on sustainability. The next School Strike for Climate takes place on the 27th September. Find more information here. 

Dr Gillian Greer Co-writer of the SDG peoples report chaired a panel discussion on gaps between where we are and where we are as reported in New Zealand’s National voluntary review on the SDG’s. You can read the peoples report here here  and the national voluntary review  here. The panel also discussed how to bridge those gaps trough collaboration. 
Read more about the summit, which plans to be hosted again nest year, here.

68th United Nations Civil Society Conference
In late August the United Nations Civil Society Conference was held in Salt Lake Utah, USA. 

The conference focused on building inclusive and sustainable cities and communities.

The Secretary-General of the United Nations reminded the conference that well planned cities equip us for inclusive societies and place us well to address the Climate Crisis. He highlighted the role of Civil Society in addressing global challenges and the importance of partnership in working toward to the Global Goals. You can see his full address here. 

You can read the full outcome statement of the conference here.

Hamilton students take on model UN! 

The Waikato branch of UNANZ hosted a Model UN event for highschool students at the end of August.

The topic of the event was a burning one: ‘Minimising the Negative Effects of Climate change’.

The event drew not just students from many schools across Hamilton but also multiple public figures. Including, the Mayor of Hamilton Andrew King, Former Chairperson of Environment Waikato, Pala Southgate and multiple member of parliament, Tim Macindoe and David Bennett who all delivered speeches to the students.

The ‘countries’ discussed their main concerns regarding the topic and outline the policies they had implemented to address them. The main issues included deforestation, extreme weather events, sea-level rise, and the resultant socio-economic implications. Many positive remedies were discussed such as reforestation, renewable energy and international cooperation to heal shared heritage.

The countries were challenged to discuss international agreements focusing specifically on the Paris Agreement and Kyoto Protocol. The countries were divided in opinion. Many highlighted poverty and population growth faced by developing countries as stumbling blocks for achieving positive targets. When debating the resolution was the hidden costs and impacts of seemingly sustainable technological innovations. Many countries called for second thought to possible consequences of new technologies and new research and development to find the most efficient alternatives to fossil fuels.

After the final voting was done, the concluding ceremony was composed of speeches from the President of the Waikato UNA NZ, the Secretary General, the judges, and one of the volunteers who is into environmental sustainability.

The prizes were distributed to the best speaker, the best team, and the team with the best costumes- notably the french delegation pictured.

Multilateralism: Time for a Revamp? Asks Helen Clark
99999999999

12th August 2019- Annual Peter Fraser Lecture, Wellington. Last month Helen Clark gave the annual lecture in the name of Rt Hon Peter Fraser. Rt Hon Peter Fraser was Prime Minister from1940-1949 who attended and played an active role in the San Francisco conference where the United Nations charter was negotiated in 1945.

Helen Clark spoke about the current state of multilateralism, the importance of staying engaged with it, seeking to improve its performance and create more inclusive forms of it.

Helen Clark noted the success of multilateralism specifically in human rights and development. She went on to discuss the pressure on the multilateral system now, discussing big challenges such as peace and security and climate action.

Finally, Helen Clark argued that a more inclusive form of multilateralism may be the way forward. She commended the ILO for its tripartite membership consisting of governments, unions and employer organisations.

She highlighted challenges for the UN and its core institutions to broaden their governance but noted lessons for the UN in the way others had broadened their stakeholder engagement. And suggested that experimenting more with that in the governance of the core multilateral system could be useful in getting broader engagement in global affairs.

You can read the full speech on Helen Clark’s website, here.

SDG focus: Action for People and the Planet

Last month saw the SDG of the month and Secretary General highlight climate change. The theme continues this month with a focus on ‘action for people and planet’

The theme comes among a month of important meeting such as the Youth Climate Summit on the 21st September. Another notable event is the Climate Action Summit, the first of its kind bringing together public and private stake holders. Finally, the Sustainable Development Goals Summit on the 24th and 25th September.

Exclusive Blog by UN Secretary-General António Guterres

The Secretary-General wrote an exclusive blog detailing his thoughts on taking action for people and the planet in a month of several important meetings.

“This month, world leaders will gather in New York for a week of critical meetings to accelerate action for sustainable development, including the Climate Action Summit and the SDG Summit. I have asked leaders to announce concrete plans of action that can boost global ambition. … If we want our planet to remain the same – healthy and able to support prosperity and opportunity for all — we will have to completely transform our world.

 

As the SDG summit takes place in New York this September key actors call for the world to ‘make it happen’.

UNA NZ Education Portal Resources

The UNA NZ Education Portal is an excellent web page for UN-related resources.  This month’s featured Portal webpage is SDG 2: Zero Hunger. Given the governments announcement of their latest policy to provide free school lunches to New Zealand’s most under privileged children and the focus on poverty in the latest access radio session (featured in this newsletter) we thought this month we would focus on SDG 2: Zero hunger.

Click here to learn more.

Wellington Access Radio featuring SDG One: No Poverty

Past President of the UNA NZ, Joy Dunsheath, will be featured monthly on Wellington’s Access Radio (106.1FM) discussing ways people can help do more to support a more just and equitable society.

This month’s programme focuses on SDG One: No Poverty with Dr Pushpa Wood and Andrew Johnston.

Listen to this episode here. 

Save the Date: UN Day 2019

On the 24th October UNA NZ will be hosting UN Day celebrations at Premier House in Wellington. The event will feature speakers such as High Commissioners. Invitations will be sent electronically via email and registration through Eventbrite is essential.

Notice: UNA NZ Office available part-time

The UNA NZ Wellington office is still available for sharing one full day or one-half day per week. It is located centrally on Boulcott St.  The office is fully furnished, and has internet connections, heating and ventilation, and an office kitchen available for use.

This would suit an NGO needing an office for one day per week or for occasional use.

For more information, please contact: Joy Dunsheath joy.dunsheath@xtra.co.nz or office@unanz.org.nz

Get your copy of our latest magazine

Be sure to check out the UNA NZ News 2018, which includes the Dame Laurie Salas Memorial Lecture, speeches and reflections from our National Conference on the topic of the role of Global Summits in solving global problems, and latest research reports by the UNA NZ. It also highlights some of the work of the wider UN family in NZ. Members should have received a copy of the magazine. If you have not received a copy, please contact your Branches. Read it now online here

Check out our newly updated website!

Selected International Days This Month

September

5 September – International Day of Charity
8 September – International Literacy Day
10 September – World Suicide Prevention Day
12 September – United Nations Day for South-South Cooperation
15 September – International Day of Democracy
16 September- International Day for the Preservation of the Ozone Layer
21 September – International Day of Peace
23 September – International Day of Sign Languages
26 September – International Day for the Total Elimination of Nuclear Weapons
26 September – World Maritime Day
27 September – World Tourism Day
28 September – International Day for Universal Access to Information
30 September – International Translation Day

October

1 October – International Day of Older Persons
2 October – International Day of Non-Violence
5 October – World Teachers’ Day
7 October – World Habitat Day
9 October – World Post Day
10 October – World Mental Health Day
11 October – International Day of the Girl Child

Share
Tweet
Forward
Copyright © 2019 United Nations Association of New Zealand
You are receiving this email because you are a member or affiliate of our organisation or have previously expressed interest in our activities. We value your feedback on the newsletter and welcome contributions.At the United Nations Association of New Zealand we are bringing people together to support the United Nations and promote its activities.UNA New Zealand
Level 13, Davis Langdon House
49 Boulcott Street Wellington 6011Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list

 

Court ordered Psychiatric Report by Nick Judson – labelled insane for protesting WTF!

This is the report ordered to establish if I could represent myself because Legal Aid refused me a lawyer for over a year.  I only go through it without huge distress and terror because of something my friend Malcolm said.  He is part of the Lake Alice group who were tortured and has fought for many years for compensation and services.   He told me when he gets a really bad report full of lies he is really pleased, cause it means he has more ammunition to fight them with.   I havn’t yet done my complaint to the Medical Council about all the lies and assumptions in the report but I will in the next few days.  So you will see just how bad it is, if you can’t work it out already its so full of BS.

I am sure people who understand what has been happening to me and how bad the mental health services are, will see the incredibly corrupt, unprofessional and bias he has shown in this report.   NOTE:  I havn’t smoked pot for years to deal with my disorder, that was in a report done about 15 years ago by the nut job ACC psychiatrist Anne Walsh (she was the lover of that psychiatrist down in Dunedin who tried to kill his wife)  only person who would pay her is ACC and she does exactly what they want.  I know for a fact she has dozens of complaints through the Health and Disability Advocacy Service.

If you remember I had my care illegally removed in 2009 by ACC and they have refused to reinstate it since that time – even though I have won two reviews.  My mental health has only worsened in that time after years of valid written and polite complaints that were ignored.  This report was done based on 1hr 20min meeting with a psychiatrist that has been an architect of abusive, oppressive and elitist mental health legislation in New Zealand.

 

PHYSCIATRIC REPORT

 

ON

 

Jayne R

 

By

 

DR NICK JUDSON, MBBS MRCPsych FRANZCP Dip.HSM

Consultant Psychiatrist

 

4 September 2019

 

PRIVATE and CONFIDENTIAL

Tel: (04) 918 2471

Fax: (04) 918 2477

PO Box 50-233

Porirua

 

………………………

 

4 September 2019

 

The Presiding Judge

District Court

MASTERTON

 

PSYCHIATRIC REPORT

 

 

Re:                     J E R……

Dob:                  xx January 1965

NHI:                   APQ 3050

 

Charges:             Wilful Damage

                             Failure to Answer District Court Bail

                             Graffiti

                             Use of offensive Language/suggestions (x2)

                               Offensive/Disturbing Use of a Telephone (x4)

                             Obscene Language (x3)

                             Wilful Trespass

                             Causing Harm by Posting Digital Communication (x3)

                             Use of Offensive Language/Suggestion

 

Psychiatric report pursuant to Section 38 of the Criminal Procedure (Mentally Impaired Persons) Act.

 

The Court has sought a report for the purpose of assisting the court to determine whether the defendant is unfit to stand trial or would have a defence of insanity within the meaning of Section 23 of the Crimes Act.

 

I met with Ms Routhan at the Masterton District Court on Thursday 29 August 2019 for the purpose of this report. At her request, a court security guard nominated by Ms Routhan sat in the interview, and a tape recording of the entire interview was made. I agreed to this recording on the basis that the recording would be held by the court. As the court will be aware, there had been some difficulty in organising an appointment that was acceptable for Ms Routhan and after some negotiation the terms of this assessment finally proved acceptable to her.

 

I have been supplied with the Summary of Facts for the various charges and a Summary of Previous Criminal and Traffic Offending. With Ms Routhan’s verbal consent I have accessed previous reports for the court prepared by Dr Justin Barry-Walsh in March 2014 and March 2019 and Dr Caroline Holmes dated May 2014 as well as a report prepared for ACC by Dr Alan Doris dated November 2008. Ms Routhan was specific in her verbal consent that these were the materials that she would permit me to access. I did not obtain written consent, as she had made it clear early in the interview that she found any ‘forms’ to be traumatic for her and I did not feel that it would be appropriate to ask her to sign a written consent form for access to the material.

 

With her permission, I have also spoken with her daughter P. M. and with her friend S. S. as well as briefly speaking to her lawyer, Mr Alisdair Ross. Ms Routhan had an understanding of the purpose of the assessment and was aware that my report would be sent to the court. She somewhat reluctantly agreed to participate in the interview.

I subsequently received an email from Ms Routhan sent via the office of the Director of Area Mental Health Services, which has added further useful information.

 

Interview

 

The interview with Ms Routhan was an extraordinary experience, particularly notable for the continual stream of personal abuse directed at the assessor. The interview was largely unstructured and was allowed to remain so, as any attempts to provide some structure to the questioning seemed to provoke even more levels of distress for Ms Routhan. She was quite clearly distressed and highly aroused by the interview situation and at times she had to pause to sit with her hands pressed to her temples to try and compose herself when her distress became too overwhelming. Her mood throughout the interview varied between anger, with invective and vicious personal abuse directed at the interviewer and at services and professionals in general, to quite marked distress and brief periods when she seemed reasonably calm for short periods and with some ironic humour. There were short periods towards the later part of the interview when she seemed to calm and almost seemed to gain some rapport with the interviewer around the issues of what may be beneficial in terms of a potential health support package. However this did not last very long and she returned to her previous pattern of angry and frustrated abuse.

 

As the court may be aware, if a transcript of the interview was accessed the abuse was continual and direct, with repeated, almost stereotyped phrases sauch as: “I hate you”, I hate your fucking guts, you piece of shit”, “you piece of garbage”, “you sick fuck”, “you elitist maggot”, you fucking elitist neo-liberal piece of shit” etc. She also directed statements about her beliefs of the Mental Health and Justice systems at the interviewer. It was evident that although these were directed towards the interviewer, they were in fact directed towards the interviewer as a representative of the system about which she feels so angry and frustrated. For example: “I know you are a murderer”, “you are dragging people into the justice system”, “you are raping those people that you lock up”, that the Mental Health system is the cause of suicides and therefore that I was murdering people and that I was personally responsible for the deficiencies in the Mental Health system.

 

She referred frequently to her views that the ‘system’, characterised by professionals, elites, foreigners, rich people, the justice system and the Police is systematically abusing poor people and actively taking pleasure in the sufferings of poor and disabled people. She expressed anger against foreigners who were moving to the country buying up property and displacing poor people like herself. She referred frequently to the traumas that she had suffered and her frustration with ACC and Mental Health Services, who had not provided her with the services that she feels she requires on terms that are acceptable to her.

 

3.

 

She referred to her own very high levels of anxiety and inability to cope when faced with any situation that may remind her of her personal experiences of abuse or trauma, or that of other people in a similar situation. These may include for example, seeing police, people with tattoos in rememberance of a suicide, any kind of forms to complete, or any contact with Police, mental health professionals or the like. Her views on professionals, elites, foreigners and Government agencies systemically abusing poor and traumatised people were expressed with a vehemence and inclusiveness that suggested a quite paranoid flavour, though there were no specifically delusional beliefs.

 

She referred to feeling constantly suicidal and said that she was unable to function effectively. She agreed that when frustrated, when her pleas for help were not met or taken seriously she “lost the plot”. She referred to this as ‘going Tourettes’, by which she meant that it seemed that her stream of abuse occurred without her necessarily intending to do so, and that this was something in the nature of an involuntary compulsive behaviour or tic. However she also talked about her behaviour as being genuine protest against Police, Government agencies and other actors in the system and seemed to have great difficulty in understanding that her behaviour was effectively self-defeating. When I tried to explore what she was trying to actually achieve with her protests this produced higher levels of anger and distress more intense abuse. She did however appear to acknowledge that her protests were more an expression of her anger and frustration than designed to achieve any specific end, though she did hope to access to suite of ACC funded services.

 

As regards the issues concerning the court, she appeared to have a good understanding of the charges in general, though I did not go through each of the charges in detail. She had a very clear view of her plea options and the defence that she wished to run. She insisted that her behaviour is justified by being political protest rather than criminal action. When attempts were made to explore her understanding of the potential consequences of the criminal charges, her response was merely that she did not care about the consequences. I was unable to ascertain to what extent she actually did have any factual understanding of the potential consequences of these charges.

 

She initially was dismissive and somewhat disparaging about her lawyer, but when asked specifically about the role of the lawyer in representing her in court she appeared to understand his role and expressed an intention to let her lawyer run her defence in the courtroom and to try and not intervene directly in the court process. She felt that, even despite the anxiety that she knew she would feel in the court situation she would manage to maintain sufficient composure to allow the lawyer to conduct the process on her behalf.

 

Ms Routhan subsequently sent me quite a lengthy email, which was articulate and much more reasonable in tone. In this she acknowleged that the abuse she had expressed was not appropriate and almost apologised: “even though I want to write those words I just can’t”. She referred to how the abuse was not intended: “…what came out wasn’t what I expected either”, and that the abuse was not personal, but was an expression of her overall frustration and rage: “What happened was you copped a lot of my unresolved rage at injustice perpetrated by other psychiatrists and mental health workers who had hurt me, discredited me, rejected me etc. Please don’t take it personally.”

 

4.

 

Current Offences

 

The current offences, 18 in all, cover a period between January 2018 and June 2019. The various offences are characterised by her abuse directed at representatives of various agencies whom she contacted in person or by telephone and by behaviour such as chalking swastikas. The charge of wilful damage arose when she threw paint over a White Ribbon banner at the police station because she objected to its comment about speaking out about violence, which she felt was hypocritical and inappropriate – she described her behaviour as ‘artistic expression’. I did not go through all the offences in detail and the court will be fully aware of the details of all the offences she is currently facing.

 

Background and Mental Health History

 

I will summarise her background and mental health history briefly as this has been well documented in previous reports.

 

Ms Routhan appears to have been a well-functioning and reasonably well-adjusted woman prior to an episode in 2002 when she was raped when asleep and intoxicated. She had had some previous mental health contact for some irritability, but no serious psychiatric problems prior to that. Following the incident of rape she developed symptoms suggestive of post traumatic stress disorder and received some mental health support funded by ACC. It appears that in 2009 she was receiving a package of care that she found particularly helpful, but for reasons that are not clear to me this was discontinued by ACC. Since then she has been increasingly angry, frustrated and despairing about mental health and support care that she has been offered, or that has been denied. I understand that numerous attempts have been made to engage her by various therapists through mental health services and ACC funded providers, but for various reasons these attempts to provide care have been unsuccessful.

 

Ms Routhan is noted to have developed high levels of anxiety, eating disorder, chronic suicidal ideation and anger, compounded by effects of cannabis use that she used to manage her mental health. She was diagnosed as suffering from a profound and enduring personality change due to the trauma of the rape. Diagnoses have varied as to whether this is PTSD, anxiety, personality change or mood disorder but however characterised there seems no doubt that this was provoked by the original episode of rape trauma and has been compounded by repeated frustrations and difficulties in her engagement with ACC, mental health and other helping agencies. Her own account is that she has been increasingly unable to function, unable to face the anxiety provoking contacts with any agencies that can support her. She gave as examples of this her inability to fill in any forms required by agencies such as Winz or ACC because of the trauma this causes her. Her friend S.. noted she experiences high levels of anxiety when she receives any communication by mail and is unable to open her mail.

 

Both her friend S.. and her daughter P…. describe her functioning as appearing to be relatively unimpaired for much of the time. However, when she has any experiences, contacts or thoughts that remind her of many of the traumas that she finds particularly anxiety provoking this can produce an overwhelming episode of anxiety which then triggers her angry response and inability to cope with the situation in which she finds herself. This may include contacts with mental health or other statutory agencies, or if she sees an item on the television or in the newspaper that reminds her of any of the issues that she is so preoccupied about. Ms Routhan has been unable to obtain any kind of employment and attributes this to lack of services and the anxiety and trauma that she experiences, further compounding her difficulties. She told me she now has only one friend and has very little other social contact.

 

5.

 

Ms Routhan is currently not receiving any mental health or ACC funded services. She has made it clear that she does not wish to receive any kind of medication. She currently has no GP. She told me that this was because the GP had imposed conditions on her behaviour that she was unable to maintain without a mental health worker and that she now requires medical intervention for physical health issues.

 

Previous Offending

 

I note that Ms Routhan has two previous convictions for graffiti in December 2017 and one of wilful trespass in May 2014. As far as I can ascertain from the records, the pattern of offending behaviour seems to have escalated in frequency and intensity over the last couple of years.

 

Opinion

 

In summary, Ms Routhan displays a picture of a woman who was reasonably functioning and relatively unimpaired in terms of her mental health and behaviour prior to an episode of rape in 2002 age 37. From this event she developed high levels of anxiety triggered by the trauma, leading to an escalating pattern of distress, mood disorder and constant preoccupation with injustices, both her own and those of society as a whole, leading to her continual episodes of ‘protest’. Her protests bring her in conflict with Police and other agencies due to her pattern of escalating abuse, which is clearly distressing and may be frightening to those who are the recipients of her abusive verbal invective.

 

  1. Mental Disorder within the Meaning of the Mental Health Act 1992

 

Ms Routan has developed a chronic mental disorder characterised by very high anxiety, volatile mood and preoccupations with systemic abuse and exploitation which border on the delusional. There are also issues of impaired volition, in that she appears by her own admission and the observations of others, to be unable to control the stream of verbal abuse when she is triggered by rejection or an event cue that heightens her anxiety. Although she calls this a type of Tourette’s syndrome (a neurological disorder characterised by compulsive verbal and other tics), it is unlikely that this would be a diagnosis. However there is a very stereotyped pattern of abuse that characterises her tirades when her anxiety and frustration is triggered beyond a certain point.   It appears that she effectively loses control and is unable to exercise any real voluntary control over her anger and verbalisation once she passes a certain trigger point. It would be reasonable to say that the first limb of the test of mental disorder, as an intermittent disorder of mood and volition, is therefore met.

 

The second limb of the test for mental disorder requires that she poses either a serious risk to others or a serious risk to her own health or safety, or is seriously diminished in her ability to care for herself. In terms of serious risk to others there is little evidence that any of her individual actions in themselves would pose a risk to another person, however it seems clear that the episodes of her abuse can lead to the victims of her abuse becoming upset, frightened and quite scared of her. I myself, an experienced psychiatrist, was taken aback by the abuse I experienced and for a lay person, particularly when caught by surprise, this is likely to be an extremely distressing and traumatic experience. Although each event in itself may not meet the criterion of seriousness, the accumulation of less serious events could be interpreted as being a serious risk to other people.

 

6.

 

Secondly considering the issue of serious risk to her own health or safety, although she claims chronic suicidal preoccupation I am not aware that there has been any suicidal behaviour, and in that sense do not think that she poses a serious risk to herself.

 

However she does put herself in situations where others react to her in a manner that may endanger her safety. For example she complains that Police have physically hurt her when restraining her, due to her behaviour when she has been highly aroused. In addition, her preoccupation and inability to resist the urge to pursue her protests and express her frustrations causes her to come up against the very triggers that re-traumatise her and heighten her anxiety and the consequences of these create a vicious cycle, steadily worsening her own mental health. This is in itself could be seen as a serious risk to her own health if the situation is maintained. She is also reckless as to the potential consequences of her repeated protests, which also may be seen as a risk to her own health and safety. Lastly considering whether there is a significant diminished of capacity to care for herself. The accounts of her daughter and her friend suggest that she is able to care for herself in practical, day-to-day issues when she is calm and functioning reasonably well. However her life situation has clearly deteriorated during the years that she has been suffering from this mental disorder. She has gone from a relatively successful and stable person to one who is living by her own account on the margins of survival, with little money and preoccupied by the injustices of her own situation and that of others. Due to this her function is in many aspects of her life seems quite seriously impaired. Issues such as her inability to deal with the agencies that she needs to help her manage her situation, her inability to complete forms, to open her mail or to attend interviews and appointments that are necessary to make some progress in her life, all suggest that there is a significant diminution in her capacity for self-care.

 

Putting this all together, it is my opinion that she does meet the definition of mental disorder as defined in the Mental Health Act and that she would potentially be eligible for compulsory intervention if this was considered to be the most appropriate step in alleviating her distress. However, her intense distrust of any aspects of the mental health system would make a compulsory intervention potentially counterproductive, re-trigger many of her traumas and enhance her sense of mistrust, with a significant risk of worsening her situation

 

  1. Fitness to Stand Trial

 

The criteria for fitness to stand trial are that she is able to plead, to understand the nature, purpose and possible consequences of the process, and to communicate adequately with counsel.

 

  • Ability to Plead: She understands the charges and can indicate clearly what is her preferred plea and why. However the defence that she is relying on may be unrealistic, in that she seems to dismiss the reality of the criminal behaviour and seems to regard her behaviour as entirely legitimate. On balance I consider that she is fit to enter a plea.
  • Ability to understand the nature of the process: I do not think this is impaired.
  • Ability to understand the purpose of the process: the answer to this would be yes in a simple sense, in that she understands that she is going to court charged with a range of offences. However her view is that the whole societal structure is one of oppression of the poor and marginalised by the elites, the professionals, Government systems etc, so that her understanding of the purpose is heavily influenced by her view that the legal process is yet another attempt to deliberately victimise her. Her full understanding of the purpose may therefore be impaired.
  • Ability to understand the possible consequences: It is very difficult to assess this given her attitude is that she does not care about the consequences. It is probably that she does understand the consequences, even if she does not accept this. Her refusal to consider the realistic consequences may affect her fitness to stand trial.
  • Ability to communicate adequately with Counsel: This is in my view the most tricky area for her in terms of her fitness to stand trial. The quality of her communication is so coloured by her distress, her anger and her frustration that it may be impossible for her to have any calm, rational discussion with her counsel about these issues. Although she is accepting at this stage the role of her counsel, and insists that she is allowing him to conduct her defence on her behalf, her volatility and impulsivity is such that she is likely to find it very difficult to maintain her composure and her stance of non-intervention in the court room.

 

In summary then my view is that there is some doubt over her fitness to stand trial, particularly given her firm insistence that she is not criminally responsible because her actions were a legitimate protest and because her ability to interact with the court as the process unfolds is likely to be impaired due to her ability to contain her distress and impulsivity during this stressful process.

 

  1. Insanity

 

Previous reports have not considered there to be an issue of insanity, though I would suggest that this a more nuanced judgement. Section 23 of the Crimes Act states that a person may be considered insane if they are suffering from a disease of the mind which makes them unable to understand the nature of the action or omission, or to understand that it was morally wrong.

 

Firstly does she have a disease of the mind? She is clearly suffering an entrenched mental disorder characterised by PTSD, mood disorder and some personality change, and also exhibits what appear to be compulsive urges to verbally abuse, as well as some degree of paranoid mood in relation to the persecution of herself and others in a similar situation. This mental disorder can be defined as constituting a disease of the mind.

 

In terms of her understanding of the nature of the action I do not consider that she would be impaired in this regard. However, does she understand that it was morally wrong? She seems to understand that the level of intensity of abuse that she allegedly perpetrates goes beyond acceptable. Her characterisation of this is “going Tourettes” indicates that she believes she cannot help herself when her anxiety reaches a certain point and that she knows that she goes beyond rationality and reasonableness with the stream of abuse that emerges when she is triggered by rejection, frustration and trauma issues. At the time these behaviours occur however, her capacity to reason or to understand the morality of what she is doing is likely to be completely overtaken by the level of personal distress and impulsive expression of her anger and frustration that she experiences. An argument can therefore be made that at the time that these behaviours occur she is incapable of understanding that her actions are morally wrong.

 

8.

 

It should also be noted that she regards her actions as being legitimate behaviour and therefore justified. On this basis she argues that it is not morally wrong. Whether this is considered to be due to mental disorder is debatable. It is difficult to see any coherent strategy from her so called ‘protest’ and her view of the injustices seems to be heavily coloured by a quasi-delusional interpretation of the malign intent of the various groupings of professionals, Police, Government agencies, and therefore can be interpreted as being a direct result of the mental disorder.

 

I would therefore suggest that the question of an insanity defence cannot be entirely ruled out in this case.

 

Comments on Disposition

 

The Court has sought advice only on the questions of fitness and insanity, however I think it would be appropriate for me to make some comments on disposition. I am very much aware that Ms Routhan finds any psychiatric assessment to be extremely distressing and anxiety provoking and anything that can be done to avoid her having to attend further psychiatric assessment is likely to be helpful for her and for the Court.

 

Ms Routhan herself suggests that she needs a package of support to assist her to manage the distress and high levels of anxiety that she currently experiences. She has at least some idea in her mind of what this would constitute. It would ideally involve mental health and support professionals who could support her in various areas of her life to manage the trauma and anxiety experiences and to enable her to get herself back into some sort of functioning occupation. She has been dismissive of the idea of any psychological input or of any medication as part of this. In order to stand any chance of successful intervention, it would be necessary to have support from a coordinated team of mental health professionals including psychiatrists, psychologists, occupation therapist, community support worker and possibly others working together to manage the various strands of her disability. I have no doubt that as part of any intervention, medication would be an important tool in alleviating the high levels of anxiety and impulsivity that occur, but this would need to be embedded in a comprehensive support package that would be acceptable to Ms Routhan and would also necessarily include some psychological work to address her Complex PTSD. To put together such a package of care would be a challenge, and to set up a package that would be acceptable to Ms Routhan would be an even more tricky challenge. In addition, it would require the mental health workers to be able to endure the kind of abuse that she would inevitably exhibit during at least the initial periods of engagement. This may be able to be tolerated if it can be conceptualised as a compulsive or tic- like behaviour that is beyond her control, and therefore not perceived as being personal abuse directed towards the therapists or care workers themselves.

 

One can see that this would be a difficult task to achieve but in my view would be the best way of ultimately being able to intervene to relieve the distress that Ms Routhan suffers. If successful such intervention may enable her to moderate her behaviour, to maintain any protests within socially acceptable boundaries and avoid the ongoing contact with Police and the Justice system. The question of compulsory intervention will inevitably need to be considered. It may be at the end of the day that compulsory intervention cannot be avoided. However any compulsory intervention by the mental health system would compound her distrust and feelings of trauma and victimisation by a system that she regards essentially abusive and should only really be considered if all other avenues to provide the care that she requires are exhausted.

 

I trust that this report is helpful to the court.

 

DECLARATION

 

I have read and complied with the Code of Conduct for Expert Witnesses contained in Schedule 4 of the High Court Rules.

 

I confirm the truth and accuracy of this statement. I make this statement with the knowledge that it is to be used in Court proceedings. I am aware that it is an offence to make a statement that is known to me to be false or intended to mislead.

 

 

 

 

DR NICK JUDSON

Consultant Psychiatrist